South Asia State of Minorities Report 2019
Buddhist Tibetans and Chakmas; Tamil Hindus from Sri Lanka;
and Rohingya Muslims from Myanmar. Those being targeted for
disenfranchisement in India are also religious minorities, mostly
Bengali-speaking Muslims in Assam and elsewhere.
We studied the consequences of migration on the lives of
the refugee subjects—by analysing their lived experiences of
deprivation and violence, their socio-economic condition, access to
basic rights, services and benefits, and their struggles for nationality
and a permanent home. In doing so, we have also tried to examine
the factors behind their difficulties, focusing on state responses,
including the legislative framework, the role of the judiciary,
state practices, and institutional mechanism and capacities as
well as the role of politics in determining outcomes. The study is
exploratory in nature, with the intent to connect accounts of the
lived experiences of refugees and the disenfranchised with key
factors that resulted in those outcomes, including the causes and
drivers of the dispossession and displacement, and accounts of
state responses.
The methodology we use is exploratory, based mostly on desk
research and supplemented by primary field exploration with
select targeted groups. We reviewed the literature available on
the refugees and stateless groups in India—to understand both
the conditions of refugees as well as the nature of state response.
This required understanding the actions of relevant stakeholders,
i.e., state actors, relief and research bodies working with specific
groups, and those living in refugee camps. To understand the lived
experiences of the groups and state response towards them, we
needed to speak to the subjects and gather first-hand data through
interviews. We conducted interviews with religious minorities
from Pakistan in refugee camps in Delhi through September and
October 2019, and in Assam to study the deprivation of citizenship.
For the latter, we relied on documentation of Misaal Foundation’s
ongoing victim support work around the ongoing NRC process,
supplemented by field data collection in Barpeta, Guwahati and
Morigaon districts in August and October 2019. Secondary literature
on refugees and migrants, including scholarly works as well as
programme documents and media accounts, were also used. To
be able to cover the range of cases, and for practical convenience,
34
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents