All Ears to the Ground
associated with EAOs have (partial) control of large swathes of territory. 119
Rohingyas in Rakhine State have fallen under the partial control of Arakan Army’s
administrative wing, the United League of Arakan. The Arakan Army includes
factions that draw on exclusionary Buddhist and ethnic nationalist ideologies that
exclude the Rohingya. For Rohingyas, this means continued and increasing
taxation, labour extraction and movement restrictions without formal recognition
of their citizenship or belonging.120 As such, where stateless communities lack
representation and power within the autonomous administrations that govern
them, they can find themselves doubly excluded.
5
Countering the conditionalities of IDs through strategic compliance and
subversion
Conditionalities are often imposed on those applying for citizenship or an
improved legal status. ID systems and registration can be imposed in ways that
require people to deny their own identity, assume a group identity by which they
do not self-identify, or go against the collective strategies of resistance including
document refusal. States can compel individuals to go through registration
processes by imposing conditions of life on the targeted group that make
functioning in society without registration almost impossible. For example, states
can curtail movement within or outside of the country for people without IDs, or
make access to work, markets and banking contingent on the possession of IDs.
In such cases, individual pragmatism comes into conflict with group loyalties. In
the case of the Rohingya in Myanmar, accepting an NVC was at times deeply
controversial within the Rohingya community, as the scheme was seen as a way
to split the community and weaponise the ID system through the denial of
recognition of Rohingya group belonging. Nonetheless, the conditions imposed on
those without NVCs had become increasingly draconian, meaning that for those
Rohingyas who wished to remain within Myanmar and continue to promote the
Rohingya cause, NVCs became a necessity.121
Activists in Myanmar sometimes accepted NVCs for the expressed reason that
it enabled them to continue their activism, for example, to document and report
abuses against Rohingya communities including citizenship violence, or in order
to provide vital humanitarian support to members of the community within the
country. All the while, they maintained their own Rohingya identity, language and
cultural practices as a form of resistance. 122 Likewise, Haqqi Bahram’s work
provides examples of how Kurdish people in Syria subverted the meaning of the
registration documents that categorised them as ajanib and maktoumeen. Instead
of focusing on the systems of discrimination that they held in place, they began to
use these documents as a symbol of Kurdish pride and identity.123 He also shows
how those who were forced to assume Arab names in order gain the benefits of
119 The extent to which ethnic armed organisations in Myanmar negotiate control over the
territory changes daily. However, for more on the development of this ongoing situation, see,
‘Myanmar’s Ethnic Armies Consolidate Strongholds as Junta Weakens, Reports Say’,
Reuters (online, 30 May 2024) <https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/myanmarsethnic-armies-consolidate-strongholds-junta-weakens-reports-say-2024-05-30/>, archived at
<perma.cc/7E66-H6C3>; David Brenner, ‘Rebel Politics after the Coup: Ethnic Armed
Organisations and Myanmar’s Spring Revolution’ (2025) Journal of Contemporary Asia 1.
120 Win and Brinham (n 49).
121 Brinham, Citizenship and Genocide Cards (n 4).
122 ibid.
123 Bahram, Between Home and Exile (n 31) 105.
27