The South African Refugees Act 130 of 1998 (the Refugees Act)
applies to all persons who wish to apply for asylum in South Africa
and defines the standard which such applicants must meet in order
to enjoy refugee status on the territory. It is the domestication in
South Africa of the 1951 Refugee Convention. It outlines the
procedure that such applicants must follow and the rights of those
whose applications are successful.
Statelessness and refugee status are separate concepts. However,
a refugee may be or may become stateless, and his or her status as
a refugee may not be linked to his or her statelessness. However,
not all stateless persons will have a fear of persecution and thus not
all will qualify as refugees. Similarly, not all refugees are stateless.
A graphic depiction of this scenario presents the following: the
groups overlap, but not entirely. Each category retains its own
separate meaning, despite the fact that some persons fall under
both categories.
Stateless
Persons
Stateless
Refugees
Refugees
Legal framework on nationality and statelessness in South Africa
3.2.5 South African Refugees Act 130 of 1998
When an applicant raises both a refugee and a statelessness claim,
it is important that each claim is assessed and that both types of
status are explicitly recognised. This is because protection under the
1951 Refugees Convention and the Refugees Act gives rise to a
greater set of rights than those available to stateless persons, for
whom no dedicated protection mechanism exists in South Africa.
Even if the 1954 Stateless Convention were applicable in South
Africa, it does not protect migrants who enter South Africa illegally
from penalisation, as does the Refugees Act.
There may also be cases where persons who have enjoyed
recognition under the Refugees Act have their status revoked and at
Promoting citizenship and preventing statelessness in South Africa: A practitioner’s guide
37