European States’ Obligations to Repatriate the Children Detained in Camps in Northeast Syria
In this briefing paper, reference is made primarily to international and
European human rights law, in particular the jurisprudence of the European
Court of Human Rights (“ECtHR”), but also to international humanitarian
law, international criminal law, international law relating to counterterrorism, the law of diplomatic and consular relations, and European Union
(“EU”) law. The legal standards and arguments examined in this briefing
paper are not exhaustive and readers are advised to check the applicable law
in each jurisdiction.
This briefing paper is structured in three sections followed by concluding
remarks. Following a note on terminology and definitions, Section I
provides an overview of the situation in the camps where the children are
currently held, and of European States’ failures to repatriate their nationals
and the children whose parent(s) are European nationals (including
undetermined nationals/children of nationals whose nationality is not yet
established in law). Section II outlines a series of legal arguments that can
be used in advocating and litigating for the proactive repatriation of those
children. Section III sets out legal arguments for the repatriation of children
together with their primary caregivers. The Conclusion is forward-looking
and highlights several key legal avenues through which repatriation cases
could be pursued.
The Open Society Justice Initiative encourages litigators and advocates to
use the research and arguments in this briefing paper to support domestic,
regional, and international advocacy and litigation. The Justice Initiative has
made every effort to ensure the information presented here is accurate. This
brief is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal
advice.
7