evidence in the record and by failing to consider material arguments they put forth. The Petitioners further contend that the BIA provided no reasoning or analysis presented in in addressing their motion the or legal when issues choosing to ignore significant and persuasive decisions on the subject. Venue for review properly lies with this Court under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(2). The Immigration Judge completed the prior proceedings in New York, New York, and, thus, wholly within this Circuit. Finally, as the Petitioners filed their Motion to Reopen with the BIA, they administrative remedies. 9 have exhausted their