Resisting Erasure
However, is it necessary to be completely rid of the boundary between stateless
and non-stateless to build empathy? Luisa Enria points out that eliciting empathy
does not require an erasure of power differentials, rather it must coax us out of a
false sense of comfort into constant problematisation and reflexivity. 24 Indeed,
whilst we must point to the similarities, one must not do this to the extent whereby
one erases the stateless experience. Basel Zaraa, a Palestinian refugee that grew
up in the Syrian refugee camp of Yarmouk, movingly displays this dynamic in his
comic ‘My Papers, My History’. Here, he narrates the experience of dealing with
the United Kingdom Home Office at the border without a recognised travel
document, namely the Palestinian travel documents accorded to Palestinian
refugees in Syria. 25 We are immersed in Zaraa’s troubling experience, as his
character is drawn with a fence or darkness in the background, emphasising the
difficulties. The final scene is a close up of his travel document suspended in a
black background. 26 This emphasis forces the reader to dwell on the luxury of
being able to travel easily. Hereby, Zaraa reconstructs an ‘us’ of those who can
travel with a recognised document and an ‘Other’ of stateless individuals who have
difficulty travelling, which brightens the boundary between stateless and nonstateless individuals. When the clerk asks him why he has this document, he gives
a detailed description of the 1948 expulsion of Palestinians into neighbouring
countries, tying his personal experience directly to the larger geo-political
context. 27 Hereby, Zaraa establishes difference and forces the reader through this
brightened boundary to problematise why it exists and how they feature within it,
forging an empathetic connection. Therefore, the reader is forced to recognise this
difference and problematise why it exists and how they feature in it, forging an
empathetic connection through difference.
24
25
26
27
Luisa Enria, ‘Co-Producing Knowledge through Participatory Theatre: Reflections on
Ethnography, Empathy and Power’ (2015) 16(3) Qualitative Research 319, 7.
Basel Zaraa, ‘My Papers, My History’, My Journey (Blog Post, 2014) (‘My Papers, My
History’) <http://myjourneymrc.tumblr.com/tagged/comics/>.
ibid 4. See also fig 8.
ibid 2–3. See also fig 9, 10.
323