SOLVING STATELESSNESS
of five. Further, Global Indicator 16.9.1 will not help the millions of
children and adults75 who lack legal identity and who may be left out of
measures that focus on ensuring birth registration for those under the
age of five. Indeed, a measure of birth registration on its own provides
a limited and inaccurate picture of who has legal identity and who does
not.76
In countries which require a national ID in order to prove nationality
and thereby access rights and services, a single measure to track
implementation of Target 16.9, such as that provided in Global
Indicator 16.9.1, poses a challenge. However, creating an additional
Global Indicator is not the solution, because an appropriate measure
in one country would not necessarily be appropriate for other national
contexts.77 Indeed, creating a new Global Indicator that would, for
example, measure the proportion of a country’s population over the
age of the 18 that holds national identity cards, could lead to States
adopting more formalised and thus potentially more restrictive
systems with respect to the issuing of national IDs, making it even more
difficult for certain groups to gain access to such documentation. This
could inadvertently expose more people to the risk of statelessness
and potentially aggravate the impact of statelessness by making
those without an ID more noticeable. Strengthening nationality
documentation systems without critically assessing and responding to
the broader governance context can lead to a number of consequences
that further entrench exclusion and thereby undermine development
gains. Action 8 of the GAP (which is the #IBelong Campaign’s partial
correlate to Target 16.9), requires that those with an entitlement to
nationality are able to acquire documentary proof of nationality.
Accordingly, it may be most appropriate for supplementary countryspecific indicators to be established in those countries which impose
proof-of-nationality requirements and for these indicators to be
administered through national censuses or other periodic population
surveys such as the United States Agency for International Development
supported Demographic and Health Surveys.
75
76
77
For example, it was reported that 750 million children under the age of 16 were
without birth registration in 2014. See, C. Dunning, A. Gelb and S. Raghavan,
Birth registration, Legal Identity and the Post-2015 Agenda, Centre for Global
Development 2014, Policy Paper 046.
See, González López, et al., supra n50, p. 1.
Ibid.
67
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents