South Asia State of Minorities Report 2019
citizens.49 And, in 1997, under political pressure, the Election
Commission of India launched its own programme to mark out
foreigners, identifying ‘doubtful’ voters and removing names from
voter lists, again all through the FTs. Since 1985, some 100,000
persons have been declared foreigners, with a steep uptick since
2016, when BJP took power in Assam. Two thirds of these were in
ex parte proceedings, where the accused never got a chance to make
their case before the bench.50 Individuals declared as foreigners,
whose appeals in higher courts have been turned down, end up in
detention centres where conditions are grim. In July 2019, India’s
Home Ministry revealed in Parliament that Assam’s six functional
detention centres housed 1133 such declared foreigners.51
While the NRC and associated exercise was designed primarily
to drive Bengali-speaking Muslims out of the state, its actual
impact has cut across religious, ethnic and linguistic minorities.
Even among the minorities, the most affected are the poor and
the vulnerable who cannot afford effective legal representation.
Particularly at risk are women, many of whom have married
young and moved away to their husbands’ villages, with no
official documentation to prove their link to their families and to
their places of birth. The documents they can manage to produce,
usually issued by village-level authorities, are often considered
inadequate by the FTs. The uncertainty and resultant panic have
contributed to a spate of suicides by people who fear the indignity
of disenfranchisement and the horror of detention. By June 2019,
Citizens for Justice & Peace (CJP), a human rights organisation,
had tracked 51 such cases in the state, with most of them being
reported since the publication of the first draft list in January 2018.52
Many more suicides have been reported since the publication of
the final list.53
49 ‘SC Strikes down IMDT Act as Unconstitutional,’ The Economic Times, July
13, 2005, https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/sc-strikes-down-imdt-act-asunconstitutional/articleshow/1168803.cms?from=mdr.
50 ‘Unstarred Question No. 1724,’ Supplementary Questions, Parliament of
India, last modified July 2, 2019, http://loksabhaph.nic.in/Questions/QResult15.
aspx?qref=1909&lsno=17.
51 Ibid.
52 Ibid.
54 ‘Fear over NRC Grips West Bengal, Two More Commit Suicide,’ The Times
of India, September 24, 2019, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/fear-
58
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents