Migrants, Refugees and the Stateless in India
situation of refugees in India, their living conditions, and especially
their access to ‘rights’ and basic services is very poor. The lack of a
uniform national refugee law also means that different groups are
treated differently and arbitrarily, with refugee protection being
delivered in an ad hoc manner. The response received by refugees
from the local population has also been varied, with some groups
being treated with suspicion, while others are more positively
received. While there is a marked contrast in the stated government
policy towards persecuted non-Muslims and Muslims,19 the
living conditions reported by all of them are broadly similar:
poor security, lack of basic amenities, including sanitation, poor
healthcare and education facilities, and limited employment and
livelihood opportunities. Access to education and healthcare are
abysmal, particularly for those living in camps. Private schools and
hospitals are uniformly preferred, but few can afford them. With
some exceptions, employment is limited to petty, informal, dailywage labour across groups. In almost every case, in the absence of
tangible action at different levels of government, civil society has
been forced to step in and try to provide the little service it can.
There are no official figures for the number of Pakistani Hindus
in India, but there are over 400 settlements for them in the state of
Rajasthan alone.20 Education and healthcare facilities are generally
poor, with civil society organisations having to step in.21 Lack of
employment opportunities continues to be a challenge despite
Hindus from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan being viewed
favourably by the present national government.
Women have reported facing a different set of problems such
as being married off at extremely young ages to protect their
‘honour’ and being forced to bear multiple children. ‘Most deliver
babies outside of hospitals, and maternal and infant mortality rates
19 The non-Muslims are treated favourably by the state while the Muslims,
mainly, Rohingya Muslims from Myanmar and Muslims from Bangladesh, are
viewed with suspicion and treated with hostility.
20 Shweta Desai, ‘Pakistani Hindus 'Unwelcome' in India,’ Al Jazeera, February
18, 2014, https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2014/02/pakistani-hindusunwelcome-india-201421063012210386.html.
21 Anam Ajmal, ‘For Pak Hindus, Home Is Where the Mind Is without
Fear,’ The Times of India, March 29, 2019, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.
com/city/delhi/for-pak-hindus-home-is-where-the-mind-is-without-fear/
articleshow/68621792.cms.
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents