Key recommendations
The UK should implement an accessible procedure to identify
stateless persons on its territory.
1
The most effective way to ensure the UK meets its international obligations to
stateless persons under the 1954 Convention and in human rights law is through
the adoption of an accessible and efficient statelessness determination procedure
that identifies stateless persons on UK territory as quickly as possible. Where
such a procedure establishes that an individual does in fact possess a nationality
permitting return, this could help facilitate the operation of immigration control.
Likewise, such a procedure could identify a nationality to which a stateless person
may be entitled, or a state where a stateless person may be entitled to return and
reside, and where their human rights will be respected.
2
The UK should review its approach to the identification of stateless persons,
and adopt a position in accordance with forthcoming UNHCR Guidelines on the
definition of “stateless person” in international law.
Currently, in both immigration and nationality law, the burden of proof is placed
on the individual to substantiate any claim that he or she is stateless, rather than
being shared between the State and the individual. This research found that many
applicants were frustrated in their efforts to obtain proof from foreign authorities
or consular authorities in the UK, which regularly refused to respond to enquiries
or to formally provide notification that an individual was not considered one of
their nationals. The qualitative research found that, even when such confirmation
was provided, the UK Border Agency would sometimes continue to attribute that
nationality to the individual.
UK Border Agency guidelines and the decisions of the courts alike provide some
guidance on whether a foreign State considers an individual to be a national under
the operation of its law. Neither, however, fully corresponds to the conclusions of
expert meetings convened in 2010 and 2011 to help develop UNHCR Guidelines.
The UK’s approach to this issue should be reviewed in the light of the forthcoming
Guidelines.
The UK should grant leave to remain to stateless persons
in appropriate circumstances.
3
In the past, stateless persons without leave to remain were, in defined
circumstances, granted indefinite leave to remain in the UK. This was the first
step by which they could acquire a nationality and end their statelessness. The
research has shown that a return to a policy granting leave to remain to stateless
persons in appropriate circumstances would also ensure respect for stateless
persons’ rights under the 1954 Convention and international human rights law.
Such an approach is reflected in current practice among those States that have
in the United Kingdom
9