In addition to the problems identified within the current legal and policy framework, there is
significant evidence that statelessness is not appropriately identified within the operation of
immigration control. The evidence indicates that this is true both when an individual presents
initially to the UK Border Agency but, also, in the context where the Agency is seeking to redocument a non-national for the purposes of removal. The lack of appropriate identification
of statelessness resulting from the lack of a statelessness determination procedure potentially
contributes to inefficient border control. In addition, there is evidence that the current
framework contributes to profound human rights concerns for stateless persons on the UK
territory, which will be discussed in detail in the next chapter.
Recommendations
The UK should incorporate the 1954 Convention into domestic law to ensure that
stateless persons in the UK are able to access their rights guaranteed under the
Convention.
The Home Office and UK Border Agency should develop an accessible procedure
for identifying stateless persons on the territory in order to meet the UK’s legal
obligations under the 1954 and 1961 Conventions and in international human
rights law.
The Home Office and UK Border Agency should develop guidance on the
identification of stateless persons and adopt a position in accordance with
forthcoming UNHCR Guidelines on the definition of “stateless person” in
international law. In particular this guidance should ensure that the burden of
proof is shared between the applicant and the State and that the approach to
assessing evidence meets the developing understanding of the interpretation and
application of Article 1(1) of the 1954 Convention. It should make it clear that
statelessness may only become apparent during the process of documentation to
allow a person to return to a foreign State, and in the light of responses received
from that State’s consular or other national authorities.
The UK government should ensure that legal aid is available to stateless persons,
who cannot afford to pay for a lawyer themselves, and are seeking to have their
status recognised. Legal aid is a necessary part of an efficient procedure for
determining statelessness and helps to ensure that the UK’s legal obligations
under the 1954 Convention and in international human rights law are met.
in the United Kingdom
89
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents