THEMATIC BRIEFING | SEPTEMBER 2021
Statelessness determination and protection in Europe
17
In Ukraine, there is no referral mechanism from refugee status determination
procedures to the SDP, but there is a mechanism to refer an applicant for statelessness
status to the asylum procedure if grounds for asylum are identified during the SDP.
There is also a mechanism to refer to a procedure to determine Ukrainian nationality
if a possible entitlement emerges during the SDP. In Bulgaria and Moldova, there
is no formal referral mechanism, but the asylum and SDP procedures are linked in
law to protect stateless applicants from contact with the authorities of the country
of origin if an asylum procedure is initiated. This is also the case in France, where
the law establishes the primacy of asylum claims. If refugee status is granted to a
stateless person in France, they are formally granted ‘stateless-refugee’ status so
there is no need to initiate a separate SDP. However, if refused asylum, the SDP is not
automatically initiated even if there are indications that the person could be stateless
(although the authorities should inform the person about the possibility of applying to
the SDP).
In Bulgaria, Hungary, Moldova, and the United Kingdom, UNHCR has a role in the
procedure. In the United Kingdom, an internal quality assurance system requires at
least one decision per examiner to be reviewed each month and UNHCR has recently
undertaken and published a detailed audit of the SDP.61
GOOD PRACTICE
Procedural safeguards in Hungary
In Hungary, free legal aid is available to all SDP applicants with no need to
meet financial eligibility requirements. Legal representatives can be present
and comment in interviews, which are mandatory in all cases. Interviews are
conducted with interpreters provided by the State if required. Documents
can be submitted in any language and there is no requirement for a certified
translation. Decisions must be given in writing with reasons within 45 days
unless there is a delay on the part of a foreign authority (although in practice
there can be significant delays). Quality assurance audits are conducted
annually in cooperation with UNHCR.62
Barriers
Lack of access to legal aid
Access to legal aid varies greatly between countries with SDPs. Some offer no legal aid
at all for an SDP application, while others make it subject to a strict eligibility test. In
Spain, SDP applicants are not generally eligible for legal aid but may be able to access
legal assistance if they are admitted to an asylum reception centre. In parts of the
United Kingdom (England and Wales), SDP applicants only qualify for legal aid if they
are unaccompanied minors or victims of trafficking or qualify for Exceptional Cases
Funding.63 In Italy and Latvia, legal aid is deemed unnecessary for administrative
procedures. In Bulgaria, legal assistance is provided by NGOs, but access is hindered
by language barriers, lack of awareness, and cumbersome procedures. In Switzerland
and Italy (judicial procedure), legal aid is only available to those who meet low-income
requirements, and in Switzerland, the applicant must additionally show they have
some prospect of success.