128
Gábor Gyulai
a fancy and perfectly equipped concert hall where no concert ever takes
place. They are still good for impressing foreign delegations or the press,
but they will never reach the objective for which they have been built.
The first question to answer, therefore, relates to the initiation of the
procedure. In most cases, if a person seeks the recognition of a certain legal
status or residence entitlement, it is required that she or he – as the interested person – initiates the procedure that would establish this entitlement (e.g. through submitting an application for asylum, a work visa or
naturalization). An important argument against simply applying this
general principle to statelessness determination is that even the persons
concerned may often have difficulties recognizing or accepting that they
are stateless, which may significantly delay their access to a proper legal
status.40 This particularly concerns vulnerable groups, such as unaccompanied minors. Another reason for opting for a different approach is the
declaratory character of the recognition of statelessness (i.e. the recognition and the consequent grant of a protection status does not create statelessness, it only recognizes this condition).41 It is thus unsurprising that
UNHCR argues that ‘Given that individuals are sometimes unaware of
statelessness determination procedures or hesitant to apply for statelessness status, procedures can usefully contain safeguards permitting State
authorities to initiate a procedure.’42
Nevertheless, there appears to be some general reticence about an ex
officio-initiated statelessness determination procedure, the main argument being that a state authority cannot ‘force someone to be stateless’.
At the time of writing, only Spain and Moldova provide for such a possibility in their legislation.43 Several avenues are available for states seeking
a balance between the two options. For instance, ex officio initiation can
be allowed, but the explicit consent of those found to be stateless shall be
obtained before recognition. Another option is to limit ex officio initiation to unaccompanied minors, or other groups or individuals lacking
40
41
42
43
See the general characteristics of statelessness (hidden phenomenon, lack of awareness,
vulnerability of the population concerned, etc.) as described earlier.
See UNHCR, ‘Guidelines on Statelessness No. 1: The defi nition of ’Stateless Person’ in
Article 1(1) of the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons’ (20 February
2012), para. 9.
UNHCR, ‘Guidelines on Statelessness No. 2: Procedures for Determining whether an
Individual is a Stateless Person’, para. 16.
Royal Decree 865/2001 of 20 July approving the Regulation for the Recognition of the
Status of Stateless Persons, s. 2(1); Act 200 of 16 July 2010, on the Regime of Foreigners
in the Republic of Moldova (Legea Nr. 200 din 16.07.2010 privind regimul stră inilor în
Republica Moldova), s. 87(1).
9781107032446c05_p116-143.indd 128
6/16/2014 3:12:02 PM
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents