ligation? Surely a voluntarily stateless person with residency in a given country would
be expected to obey criminal law and pay taxes on goods and income, but can they be
expected to participate in compulsory military service, or jury duty? And what of those
voluntarily stateless individuals who do not hold legal residency? What are the expectations that can be reasonably placed upon them?
On the other side of the duty coin, what obligations does a state have towards
voluntarily stateless persons who reside on their territory? Does a voluntarily stateless
person renounce with their citizenship their ‘human’ rights to health care and education,
for example? Does a state’s moral duty, typically reserved for refugees, extend to those
who choose to exist outside of the purview of the state? This dilemma has presented
itself as it relates to undocumented people, but the difference here is that undocumented people are citizens of somewhere. It can be generally assumed that they have merely reprioritized the state which they choose to obey. They have not renounced the idea
of obligation in totality. What can this tell us about how the state should interact with
those residing in a polity which they at the same time reject?
Membership
From republication values of public participation to liberal individuality to post-modern
perspectives on belonging, membership is a deeply contested idea. But what unites
these myriad positions is that there is value in belonging at some level.
Voluntary statelessness thus presents a unique challenge to what we know about
how shared values are perceived. Choosing to disengage from the state system is not
only an act of resistance against the state’s omnipresence, but more importantly, for the
individual it is a provocative statement against the notion of shared values, and for
communities it can be seen as a challenge to the disconnect between their values and
those of the state in which they reside.
“Voluntary statelessness, therefore, necessitates a rethinking of the foundations of political thought referring to, at
the very least, participation, civic virtue, the common
good, friendship, and social relations”
Shared values have guided community development for millennia. They sustain
us in times of conflict, differentiate between cultures, and contribute to what some refer
to as the strength of diversity. Voluntary statelessness, therefore, necessitates a rethinking of the foundations of political thought referring to, at the very least, participation,
civic virtue, the common good, friendship, and social relations. Western systems of
government are founded upon the notions of representation and equality. What is the
value of political participation if people choose to disengage from systems of representation?
http://community.apsanet.org/migrationcitizenship/home
50