Human Rights Brief, Vol. 24, Iss. 2 [2020], Art. 5 44 :&%+*1.2 "9?&G@ O++6(&G Q$)$(9(++&0%19.#(*Z+&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B&1*&2%1*)& 0)**"$&,(&.1+06++(.&1*&1+"9)$1"*&/#"7&!"#$%&'"#()*& ;"7(*&#(/6-((+Z&#1-%$&*"$&$"&,(&#(D)$#1)$(.?&!"#$%& '"#()*&;"7(*&/()#&0"7D#"71+1*-&$%(1#&.(/(0$"#& +$)$6+&,B&09)171*-&$%(1#&0%19.#(*Z+&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B?& w#"$(0$1"*&/#"7&#(/"69(7(*$&1+&0#601)9&)*.&(++(*$1)99B& $%(&+"9(&%1*.#)*0(&$"&!"#$%&'"#()*C2%1*(+(&+$)$(9(++& 0%19.#(*&)0€61#1*-&$%(1#&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B?3K& O*$(#*)$1"*)9&%67)*&#1-%$+&0"*A(*$1"*+&0"*.(7*& #(/"69(7(*$?&`1#+$8&=#$109(&4^3_&"/&$%(&2J2&D#"$(0$+& 0%19.#(*&)*.&D)#(*$+&/#"7&/"#0(.&+(D)#)$1"*?&Q(0"*.8& =#$109(&xx&"/&$%(&34E@&J(/6-((&2"*A(*$1"*&+$#"*-9B& D#"$(0$+&!"#$%&'"#()*&.(/(0$"#+&/#"7&#(/"69(7(*$& ,B&(RD9101$9B&D#"%1,1$1*-&#(/"69(7(*$&"/&)&#(/6-((& ""#!;.1.<0$%!"$%.&$0%+'$01!=)80$!;+>-%2!?0@ S;%(#(&%1+&91/(&"#&/#((."7&;"69.&,(&$%#()$(*(.?Y3N& >)W"#&1*$(#*)$1"*)9&%67)*&#1-%$+&1*+$#67(*$+&0"*$)1*& <%1#.8&=#$109(&x^3_&"/&$%(&2=<&#(1*/"#0(+&D#"%1,1$1"*& )&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B&)*.&)&*"*C.1+0#171*)$1"*& "/&#(/"69(7(*$&;%(#(&+6,+$)*$1)9&-#"6*.+&(R1+$&/"#& 09)6+(&$"&(*+6#(&(€6)9&D#"$(0$1"*&"/&$%(+(&#1-%$+?&<%(& .)*-(#&"/&,(1*-&+6,W(0$(.&$"&$"#$6#(?34&}($8&2%1*)& \L]J&.(09)#(+&1*&=#$109(&`1|((*&$%)$&S(A(#B"*(& 0"*$1*6(+&$"&*"$&0"7D9B&;1$%&1$+&",91-)$1"*+&$"&$%(& %)+&)&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$BY&)*.&$%)$&*"&"*(&+%"69.& 1*$(#*)$1"*)9&0"776*1$B? ,(&S)#,1$#)#19B&.(D#1A(.&"/&%1+&*)$1"*)91$B?Y3G&<;"& w6#+6)*$&$"&A)#1"6+&+"6#0(+&"/&1*$(#*)$1"*)9&%67)*& 1*$(#*)$1"*)9&$#()$1(+8&$%(&2J2&1*&=#$109(&K^3_&)*.&$%(& #1-%$+&9);8&Q$)$(+&w)#$1(+&%)A(&)*&)M#7)$1A(&.6$B&$"& O22wJ&1*&=#$109(&G@^x_8&*"$&"*9B&#(1*/"#0(&$%(&#1-%$& (*+6#(&(*W"B7(*$&"/&$%(&/"99";1*-&#1-%$+o&+$)$(9(++& $"&*)$1"*)91$B&,6$&)9+"&(RD9101$9B&(R$(*.&$%(&#1-%$&$"& 0%19.#(*Z+&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B8&0%19.#(*Z+&#1-%$&)-)1*+$& )99&0%19.#(*?3x&&<%(&D"910B&"/&*"*C.1+0#171*)$1"*&1*& .1+0#171*)$1"*&/"#&,(1*-&,"#*&"/&)&!"#$%&'"#()*& $%(&2J2&)*.&$%(&O22wJ&)9+"&D#"$(0$+&!"#$%&'"#()*& .(/(0$"#&7"$%(#8&)*.&$%(&+$)$(9(++&0%19.#(*Z+&7"$%(#+Z& #(/6-((+Z&0%19.#(*Z+&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B&,(0)6+(&,"$%& #1-%$&/"#&D#"$(0$1"*&)-)1*+$&#(/"69(7(*$&$"&!"#$%& 0"*A(*$1"*+&+D(01X0)99B&D#"%1,1$&.1+0#171*)$1"*&,)+(.& '"#()?&=#$109(&G4^G_&"/&$%(&O22wJ&#(€61#(+&()0%& "*&*)$1"*)9&"#&+"01)9&"#1-1*8&,1#$%&"#&"$%(#&+$)$6+?3@& >(7,(#&Q$)$(&$"&ST6*.(#$):(U&?&?&?&*(0(++)#B&+$(D+& <%(&2J2Z+&*"*C.1+0#171*)$1"*&09)6+(&0"*$)1*+& ?&?&?&$"&-1A(&((0$&$"&$%(&#1-%$+Y&1*&$%(&2"A(*)*$?G5& )*&(9(7(*$&(++(*$1)9&$"&0"7,)$1*-&.1+0#171*)$1"*& Q1719)#9B8&=#$109(&K^G_&"/&$%(&2J2&#(€61#(+&Q$)$(+& $";)#.&!"#$%&'"#()*&#(/6-((+Z&+$)$(9(++&0%19.#(*& w)#$1(+&$"&S(*+6#(&$%(&17D9(7(*$)$1"*Y&"/&$%(&#1-%$& ,B&D#"%1,1$1*-&.1+0#171*)$1"*&,)+(.&"*&$%(&0%19.Z+& $"&)0€61#(&)&*)$1"*)91$B?G3&<%(&2J2Z+&17D9(7(*$)$1"*& D)#(*$+?3E&<%(&O22wJ&7"#(&,#").9B&,6$&(7D%)$10)99B& D#"A1+1"*&1+&.1+$1*0$&/#"7&$%(&O22wJ8&%";(A(#8& .(09)#(+&D#"$(0$1"*&"/&$%(&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B&,B& ,(0)6+(&1$&#(€61#(+&0"7D91)*0(&1*&)00"#.)*0(&;1$%& D#"%1,1$1*-&.1+0#171*)$1"*&,)+(.&"*&S.1+$1*0$1"*&"/& Q$)$(+&w)#$1(+Z&",91-)$1"*+&*"$&"*9B&6*.(#&$%(&2J2&,6$& )*B&:1*.?Y3I 2"A(*)*$&"*&21A19&)*.&w"91$10)9&J1-%$+&^O22w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yO&L($)19(.&J(D"#$8&%&'()$*"$(&G&)$&¶¶&@KG‚Kx?& &\?Q?&L(D)#$7(*$&"/&Q$)$(8&H+,$?1)1&%$28$Q2(1+$=2(,)0$C%3:&/$ ?,,S,(%$)0#$1+,$A?9$;2:.<3$H25)(#%$H+,/8&^G55E_?& 34 &2"*A(*$1"*&=-)1*+$&<"#$6#(&)*.&y$%(#&2#6(98&O*%67)*&"#&L(C -#).1*-&<#()$7(*$&"#&w6*1+%7(*$8&2',0,#$82($%.>0)1&(,$L(0?&358& 34N@8&3@IE&\?!?<?Q?&NE&T%(#(1*)|(#&\!2=<U&^.(X*1*-&$"#$6#(&)+8& ST)U*B&)0$&,B&;%10%&+(A(#(&D)1*&"#&+6(#1*-8&;%($%(#&D%B+10)9&"#& 7(*$)98&1+&1*$(*$1"*)99B&1*H10$(.&"*&)&D(#+"*&/"#&+60%&D6#D"+(+&)+& ?&?&?&D6*1+%1*-&%17&/"#&)*&)0$&%(&"#&)&$%1#.&D(#+"*&%)+&0"771$$(.& "#&1+&+6+D(0$(.&"/&%)A1*-&0"771$$(.Y_? G5 &O22wJ8&%&'()$*"$(&3x8&)$&)#$?&G4^G_? G3 &2J28&%&'()$*"$(&3@8&)$&)#$?&K^G_?& 3K& 3N &ƒ?=?&J(+?&G3K&^OOO_&=8&\*1A(#+)9&L(09)#)$1"*&"/&]67)*&J1-%$+8& )#$?&3E&^L(0?&348&34@N_&T%(#(1*)|(#&\L]JU? 3x &O*$(#*)$1"*)9&2"A(*)*$&"*&21A19&)*.&w"91$10)9&J1-%$+&)#$?&G@8& 2',0,#$82($%.>0)1&(,$L(0?&3I8&34II8&444&\?!?<?Q?&3K3&T%(#(1*)|(#& O22wJU? 3@ &2"*A(*$1"*&"*&$%(&J1-%$+&"/&$%(&2%19.8&2',0,#$82($%.>0)1&(,& !"A?&G58&34N48&3EKK&\?!?<?Q?&x&T%(#(1*)|(#&2J2U„&O22wJ8&%&'()& *"$(&3x8&)$&=#$?&G^3_?& 3E &2J28&%&'()$*"$(&3@8&)$&)#$?&G^3_?& 3I& O22wJ8&%&'()$*"$(&3x8&)$&)#$?&G^3_? 3G