stateless status and expulsion from italian territory
155
consequently, Article 31 of the New York Convention of 1954 Relating to the
Status of Stateless Persons (hereinafter: “New York Convention”),1 according
to which a stateless person cannot be expelled except for reasons of national
security or public order, was applicable.
Key Passages from the Ruling
(Paragraph 1) “[…] the condition of de facto statelessness is not a condition
preventing the expulsion of a foreigner, since, according to the New York
Convention of 1954 […], the status of stateless person can be recognized only
to those who lack citizenship in the State with which they have had or have a
connection […].
The New York Convention of 1954 considers stateless only those who are
deprived of nationality and have not been able to obtain it in any State under
its own legislation; those who, being able to obtain nationality under the legislation of their country of origin, have not taken steps to obtain it are not
stateless.
In the present case, […] the defendant was unable to obtain the citizenship
of his mother’s country of origin (Serbia) and his father’s country of citizenship (Kosovo).
The trial judge should have verified whether the defendant, since he was
born and raised in Italy, a country with which he actually had a significant
connection, should be considered stateless. If so, it should have held that the
protection under Article 31 of the New York Convention of 1954, under which
a stateless person may not be expelled except on documented grounds of
national security and public order, extended to the person concerned”.
Comment
1
Background to the Case
The police authority of Brescia (Italy) ordered twice, in 2015 and 2016, Mr. D.A.
to leave the national territory. As a result of his failure to comply with such
orders, Mr. D.A. was convicted by the Giudice di Pace di Brescia of the crime
provided for in the Italian Immigration Act (Testo unico sull’immigrazione,
1 New York Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, 28 September 1954, entered
into force 6 June 1960.
The Italian Review of International and Comparative Law 2 (2022) 154–162