Statelessness Working Paper Series No. 2016/02
of legal identity. Islamic State takeover of territory in recent years has left many Internally Displaced
Persons in Iraq unable to acquire identity documents necessary to access basic services,12 while their
unregistered new-born children, like those of Syrian refugees in the country, can be at increased risk
of becoming stateless.13
In KR-I, stateless Kurds – like fellow Syrians – have come into direct and regular contact with agencies
of the humanitarian community, and qualify for assistance and international protection under
UNHCR’s refugee mandate. In contrast, while the non-refugee stateless are also mandated Persons of
Concern to UNHCR,14 due to political sensitivities back home in Syria, the stateless Kurds there found
themselves positioned “beyond UN assistance.”15 Despite significantly increased access to the
community in the Kurdistan Region, UNHCR has done little to map statelessness among the Syrian
Kurdish refugee population. Rather, for both convenience and in order to provide the highest possible
level of protection, UNHCR does not distinguish between the various nationality statuses –
citizen/ajnabi/maktum – when determining and registering Syrians as refugees.16 Indeed, this is in line
with UNHCR’s statistical reporting whereby ‘stateless refugees’ are counted as refugees and excluded
from data on stateless persons in order to avoid double counting.17
Likewise, it is the policy of the Kurdistan Regional Government not to ask about the nationality status
of Syrian refugees.18 As such, ajanib and maktumeen are provided the same legal protection as other
refugees. Besides a few reports of difficulties and delays in completing residency paperwork,19 those
Kurdish refugees who are also stateless do not appear to experience specific protection concerns while
in the Kurdistan Region. An indirect (and adverse) result of such policies, however, is the lack of
reliable information on the number of stateless Syrian Kurds, since their statelessness is invisible
within official statistics.20 It is important to note that while the scale of the statelessness problem and
the potential vulnerabilities of this population are largely obscured when in the Kurdistan Region,
protection concerns are often (re-)activated as stateless Kurds travel to third countries outside Syria
and Iraq. More thorough mapping of statelessness in Kurdistan may, therefore, be particularly
relevant given the large number of stateless Kurds who have left KR-I and/or Syria and risked
journeying illegally to Europe over the last year.
Many people remain stateless in the Kurdistan Region as a result of two significant limitations
associated with the scope and implementation of Decree No. 49’s provisions for naturalisation. 21
Firstly, its failure to mention the maktumeen-status Kurds means that they are in practice excluded
12
Julia St. Thomas King and Dennis Ardis, ‘Identity crisis? Documentation of the displaced in Iraq’ (November 2015)
Humanitarian Exchange 65 <http://odihpn.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/HE_65_web.pdf>.
13 Salar Salim and Susannah George, ‘Thousands of Syrian refugee children in Iraq left in “legal limbo”’ The Independent (29
November 2015) <http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/thousands-of-syrian-refugee-children-in-iraqleft-in-legal-limbo-a6753531.html>.
14 UNHCR/Division of International Protection (DIP), Note on the Mandate of the High Commissioner for Refugees and his
Office, (2013) p. 8.
15 Taghee Moas, ’62 years of Human Rights, yet no rights since ‘62’, (Fall 2010) Rights in Review 3, p. 10
<www.jhr.ca/downloads/Rightsinreview_Fall_2010.pdf>.
16 Stateless status is not currently indicated in the refugee profiles maintained on UNHCR’s specialized ProGres registration
software for those in the Kurdistan Region.
17 Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion, The World’s Stateless (Wolf Legal Publishers, 2014), p. 10.
18 In an interview during March 2016, an official stated that the KR-I government “refuses to respect the discriminatory
differentiations imposed on Kurds by the Syrian government.”
19 It is perhaps significant to note that these cases were reported by stateless Kurds based in Sulaimaniya governorate in
KR-I.
20 Challenges associated with accurately quantifying statelessness have been highlighted in Institute on Statelessness and
Inclusion, The World’s Stateless (Wolf Legal Publishers, 2014).
21 Limitations of the decree are further compounded by the dimension of gender discrimination already built into Syrian
nationality legislation, as is the case in many other countries in the Middle East region.
3