8
Can’t Stay. Can’t Go. Refused asylum seekers who cannot be returned
they are destitute adds practical problems since
they cannot afford to pay for travel to visit their
embassy or to send faxes and make phone calls
(AIDA 2015). The absence of, or loss of contact
with, family members still living in their country of
origin who could help them to acquire documents
further compounds their difficulties.
Given the strict criteria for obtaining Section 4
support, it is not surprising that, as of the end of
September 2016, only 2,441 main applicants were
being supported under Section 4 (Home Office
2016e). Most of those on support had submitted
further representations. Very few people are granted
Section 4 support under the criteria of taking all
reasonable steps to leave the UK. Home Office
records indicate that, in 2015, only 63 destitute,
refused asylum seekers were granted Section 4
support on this ground (Brokenshire 2016).
1.2.2 Section 95A
The Immigration Act 2016 (HM Government 2016)
received royal assent on 12 May 2016 and makes
key changes to the existing support framework.
Much of the detail of the provisions has been left
to the awaited regulations, which will need to
be drafted and laid before Parliament before the
changes come into force. Once the Minister has
approved the draft regulations, the timetable for
implementation will become much clearer.
Paragraph 1, Schedule 11 of the Act repeals
Section 4 for single adults. There will be some
transitional protection for those currently receiving
Section 4 support; however, the detail of this
transition is not yet known. Paragraph 9, Schedule
11 of the Act allows for asylum seekers who reach
the end of the process, but who face a “genuine
obstacle” to leaving the UK, to be supported under
a new provision, Section 95A (HM Government
2016). What is meant by “genuine obstacle” is
yet to be defined. This new statutory support will
be paid in cash at the same level as Section 95
support (£36.95 per week). While this is welcome,
the criteria for accessing Section 95A support
will be more restrictive than those for Section
4. Regulations will require single adults to apply
within a 21-day “grace period” after refusal of their
asylum claim (Home Office 2016f). Home Office
records indicate that, of the 63 refused asylum
seekers granted Section 4 support in 2015, only
five had applied within 21 days (Brokenshire
2016). There will be no right of appeal on refusal
of support. The lack of appeal is worrying given a
report released by the Asylum Support Appeals
Project (ASAP) in September 2014. The report
analysed 51 appeals to the First-tier Tribunal
(Asylum Support) that challenged the Home Office’s
decision to discontinue Section 4 support under
regulation 3(2)(a): Taking reasonable steps to leave.
In 75 per cent of the appeals, the Home Office’s
decision to discontinue support was overturned or
reconsidered (ASAP 2014).
The 2016 Act also removes Section 94(5) of
the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 (HM
Government 1999), which allows for asylumseeking families with children to remain supported
under Section 95 until they leave the UK.
Regulations will provide for Section 95 support to
be discontinued after a grace period of 90 days for
families whose asylum claim is finally determined
and rejected (Home Office 2016f). Section 95A
support will be available to families who are
destitute and have a “genuine obstacle” to leaving
the UK. As with single adults, there will be no right
of appeal on refusal of support.
The Home Office (2016g) factsheet on support for
certain categories of migrants states that these
measures have been framed carefully to avoid
passing the cost of supporting failed asylum
seekers and their families on to local authorities.
The Home Office states that it has consulted
local authorities and will continue to work closely
with them on the detail of the new arrangements
and implementation. It also states: “there is no
general obligation on local authorities to support
illegal migrants who intentionally make themselves
destitute by refusing to leave the UK when it is
clear they are able to” (Home Office 2016g).
1.3 The risk of statelessness
In April 2013, the UK government introduced new
immigration rules that provide for an application
to remain as a stateless person (UK Visas and
Immigration and Immigration Enforcement 2013).
Part 14 of the rules defines a stateless person as
one who is not considered as a national by any
State under the operation of its law.
Refused asylum seekers who remain in limbo in the
UK because of difficulties with proving nationality or
being re-documented are at risk of statelessness.
The European Network on Statelessness (2016: 10)
uses the term “at risk of statelessness” to refer to
individuals who are “in a place of vulnerability that
can escalate into statelessness”.
According to a best practice guide on
statelessness and applications for leave to remain
produced by the Immigration Law Practitioners’
Association and Liverpool Law Clinic (Woodhouse
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents