54
D. Case Law on the Right to Fair Administrative Action
19. Authorities had to submit confidential information in court where
a decision based on the said confidential information was being
challenged in court.
Bashir Mohamed Jama Abdi v Minister for Immigration and Registration of Persons
& 2 others [2014] eKLR
Petition 586 of 2012
High Court at Nairobi
I Lenaola, J
March 7, 2014
Even if certain material was considered classified, when a challenge was made in court, the
authorities should apply for the court to view the “closed” material for it to understand the
enormity of the threat posed by the aggrieved party. By keeping silent, the actions of the
authorities, however noble, could not pass the test of legal scrutiny.
Summary of facts
The petitioner’s son had travelled from the United Kingdom (UK) to Kenya and on
arrival at the Jomo Kenyatta International Airport, he was stopped at the Immigration
Desk and informed that he was not allowed to enter Kenya because he was involved in
terrorist activities. He was thereafter put on the next flight to the United Kingdom where
he had been living freely and without any charges being preferred against him and from
evidence on record, he was not even interrogated by British authorities on the allegations
levelled against him. The petitioner’s case was that his son was entitled to the citizenship
of the Republic of Kenya and that although his son was a naturalised citizen of the United
Kingdom, he was still entitled to the citizenship of Kenya as a dual citizen under the Kenya
Citizenship and Immigration Act, 2011. That although he had applied for a Kenyan
passport, the same had been denied unlawfully on the grounds that he was involved in
terrorist activities which allegation was unproven.
The respondent’s submissions
The respondents’ case was that the petitioner’s son was put on the Terrorist Watch List and
he was prohibited from entering Kenya in accordance with the provisions of section 33 of
the Kenya Citizenship and Immigration Act, 2011.
Key issues for determination
The main issues for determination were what was the process for re-acquiring citizenship
CITIZENSHIP AND NATIONALITY RIGHTS CASE DIGEST
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents