Stateless Persons
Fig. 3.2
Global stateless population within UNHCR mandates
The total global
stateless population
The stateless population
within UNHCR’s protection
mandate (including refugees,
asylum-seekers and IDPs)
The stateless population
exclusively within UNHCR’s
statelessness protection mandate
(i.e. non-refugees, asylum-seekers
or IDPs)
strategies to address statelessness under
this part of its mandate, and to avoid double counting of populations of concern,
UNHCR’s statistical reporting indicates
only the number of persons under its
statelessness mandate. To reach the total
figure for persons of concern to UNHCR,
this number is added to those from the
other population categories (refugees,
asylum-seekers, IDPs, etc.).
Thus, while international law defines
a stateless person as anyone who is ‘not
considered as a national by any state under the operation of its law’, in UNHCR’s
statistical compilation on statelessness,
several categories of stateless persons
are not counted as stateless. This includes
those who also fall within the protection
mandates of other agencies of the United
Nations (at present, only UNRWA) and
those who also come under UNHCR’s other protection mandates (such as refugees,
asylum-seekers, and to some extent IDPs).
Figure 3.2 demonstrates the significance
of this approach to the statistical picture
on statelessness globally.
Even if UNHCR’s statistical reporting were to capture reliable data for all
countries, then, it excludes from its statelessness statistics a significant number
of persons who are stateless as a matter
of international law. While this does not
mean that such individuals are not counted somewhere, it does make it difficult to
46
UNHCR Statistical Yearbook 2013
see the full magnitude and spread of the
statelessness phenomenon.
The Rohingya are a good case study to
demonstrate the statistical complexities
that emerge when one group has multiple protection needs. While according
to some estimates there are 1.33 million
Rohingya within Myanmar,70 another 1–1.5
million Rohingya live outside the country.71 Of the total global Rohingya population of an estimated more than 2.5 million
(of which a significant majority are stateless), only 810,000 are counted as stateless in the UNHCR statistics.72 The following groups are not included: Rohingya
refugees and asylum-seekers or those in
a refugee-like situation who are included
in UNHCR refugee statistics, Rohingya in
a refugee-like situation who are not included in UNHCR’s refugee statistics, and
Rohingya asylum-seekers whose registration is still pending.
There is also uncertainty as to whether and how Rohingya IDPs in Myanmar (of
whom there are an estimated 140,000)
and Rohingya resettled refugees (likely to
be a small group due to the lower numbers of resettlement) are represented
in the statelessness statistics. And the
Rohingya are not the only stateless group
that suffers displacement and persecution. There are other significant groups
of stateless refugees who are also ‘counted’ only in UNHCR’s refugee statistics.
Looking at stateless groups that fall under the mandates of other UN agencies
adds a further massive number of stateless Palestinian refugees, registered by
UNRWA, who are also not reflected in
UNHCR’s statistical reporting as refugees
or stateless persons. 73
Excluding these other stateless populations from the global statelessness statistics can create confusion with regard
to the situation of particular populations, as well as the application of international standards. For example, since
the onset of the Syrian crisis, the number of stateless persons reported in the
country has dropped from 300,000 at
the start of 2011 to 160,000 at the end of
2013. Only part of this reduction is due to
70 Fortify Rights, Policies of Persecution. Ending abusive
state policies against Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar, February
2014, available at: http://www.fortifyrights.org/downloads/
Policies_of_Persecution_Feb_25_Fortify_Rights.pdf.
71 This includes some 31,000 registered Rohingya refugees
in Bangladesh and another 37,000 registered in Malaysia, but
also an estimated further 300,000–500,000 unregistered
Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh according to the Government,
a few thousand unregistered in Malaysia and in Thailand, tens
of thousands in Pakistan, and hundreds of thousands in Saudi
Arabia, as well as more scattered across a number of other
countries. See, for instance, the records of a Parliamentary
debate in the United Kingdom, answers given by Ian Pearson
based on information from UK missions, on 1 February 2006,
available at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/
cm200506/cmhansrd/vo060201/text/60201w16.htm .
72 A full account of the challenges with respect to reporting
on stateless Rohingya populations is given in the report The
World’s Stateless.
73
See UNRWA in Figures, available at: http://www.unrwa.
org/sites/default/files/2014_01_uif_-_english.pdf.