Statelessness & Citizenship Review
2020
2(1)
and as a possible influence on current deliberations about how to ‘end
statelessness’. 12
II
METHODOLOGY
The historical narrative relies principally on secondary sources for accounts of
citizenship equality campaigns during the interwar period. Work particularly by
Ellen DuBois brings to life much of the colourful interactions of feminists and
their protagonists during a month-long conference on nationality in The Hague.
The work of Caroline Bredbenner is called on for her detailed descriptions of the
United States’ feminist movement against unequal citizenship laws. And, Mary
Daly’s rich account of the young Irish state’s position on GDNL in the 1920s and
’30s is the background to a case example here.
A small number of primary sources from the early 1900s are analysed within
this article. Feminist campaigners for equal citizenship in the early 1900s were
often lawyers or academics, and so their own arguments and thoughts on the issue
are important to modern scholars approaching the issue from a legal or theoretical
viewpoint. From that period, writings by US poet and activist Muna Lee are
referenced, as well as work by Scottish suffragette and barrister Chrystal
Macmillan and prominent Brazilian suffragette Bertha Lutz. A small number of
original texts by lawyers and politicians in opposition to the demands of the
citizenship equality campaigners are also analysed.
III
LIMITATIONS
This article’s heavy reliance on secondary sources has limited the focus to
citizenship equality campaigns in the Western context in the early 1900s. Little is
known, or at least written about in English — another limitation of this study —
of similar activism in other regions during that period.
IV
PART 1: FEMINIST REVISIONIST HISTORY — 1900S CAMPAIGNING
Few international questions present such conflicting and perplexing aspects as that
of the nationality of women. It is a modern question … Now [women] have been
forced into a rude awareness of the completely chaotic conditions of existing
nationality laws. 13
Muna Lee, 1929
Introduction
At the time of the First World War, nationality laws implied that a woman was
compulsorily stripped of her nationality upon marriage to a foreign man. 14 In
contradiction to the idea that the First World War brought women’s nationality
issues to the forefront, Chrystal Macmillan, in 1925, reminded readers that the
International Council of Women (the ‘International Council’) first took up the
12
13
14
Cf ‘Ending Statelessness’, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (Web Page)
<https://www.unhcr.org/en-ie/ending-statelessness.html>.
Lee (n 7) 222.
Macmillan (n 7) 154.
46