Statelessness Working Paper Series No. 2015/04
2. The ethnic Vietnamese in Cambodia
The Vietnamese are the largest minority group in Cambodia. Recent estimates suggest they make up
5% of the total Cambodian population numbering around 400,000 - 500,000.11 The Vietnamese
currently residing in Cambodia can be divided into two categories: those who are long term settlers
who have lived in Cambodia for generations, with the omission of the Khmer Rouge period where they
were forcibly deported to Vietnam and more recent migrants who have taken advantage of
Cambodia’s open market policies. I will focus on the former group as it is their children and their
children’s children who can be defined as being at high risk of statelessness, unlike the latter who are
mostly citizens of Vietnam12.
A small number of authors have written about the Vietnamese minority in Cambodia13 and even fewer
have specifically addressed the issue of nationality.14 However, when the issue of nationality has been
addressed it has been argued that the Vietnamese face a very real threat of statelessness - especially
children.15 Without citizenship and other documentation for themselves, it is extremely difficult for
ethnic Vietnamese parents to secure Cambodian nationality for their children based on Cambodia’s
Nationality Law (1996). For instance, despite introducing a jus soli provision, ethnic Vietnamese
children born in Cambodia can acquire nationality only insofar as their parents can prove that they
were either born or have lived legally in the country.16 However, most Vietnamese who returned to
Cambodia after the Khmer Rouge period lost their papers and cannot prove their residence before the
adoption of the 1994 Immigration Law; therefore their children are not considered Cambodian
citizens.17 For children to be considered Vietnamese citizens, their parents would have to apply for
naturalization.18 However, most Vietnamese who are long term residents see Cambodia as their home
and do not wish to leave. Furthermore, it is not guaranteed that the Vietnamese authorities would
recognize them as eligible for citizenship.19
Cambodia is currently not a signatory of the Statelessness Conventions but is a signatory to other
conventions with provisions to protect against statelessness. For example, Article 7 of the Convention
on the Rights of the Child specifies that every child shall “be registered immediately after birth” and
shall have “the right to acquire a nationality”. Moreover, Article 15 of the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights stipulates that “everyone has the right to a nationality” and that “no-one shall be
arbitrarily deprived of his nationality”. However, this does not seem to have made a great impact on
the lives of Vietnamese people in Cambodia who cannot claim citizenship rights and consequently face
vulnerabilities in every area of life20. For the community in Preah Thnov, parents who have attempted
to have their children registered have reported being rejected or required to pay large sums of money.
11
J Schliesinger, Ethnic Groups of Laos Vol 2: Profile of Austro-Asiatic-Speaking Peoples (BooksMango 2015).
L Nguyen & C Sperfeldt, ‘Boat Without Anchors: A Report on the Legal Status of Ethnic Vietnamese Minority Populations
in Cambodia under Domestic and International Laws Governing Nationality and Statelessness’ (2012) RegNet Research Paper
No. 2014/50; B Ang & J Chan, ‘The Situation of Stateless Ethnic Vietnamese in Cambodia LIMBO ON EARTH : An Investigative
Report On the Current Living Conditions and Legal Status of Ethnic Vietnamese in Cambodia’ (2014).
13 R Amer, ‘Domestic Political Change and Ethnic Minorities–A Case Study of the Ethnic Vietnamese in Cambodia’ (2013) 13:2
Asia-Pacific Social Science Review 87; R Amer, ‘A Minority in at Risk ?’ (1994) 16 Contemporary Southeast Asia 210; CM Tarr,
‘The Vietnamese Minority in Cambodia’ (1992) 34 Race & Class 33; Didier Bertrand, ‘Refugees and Migrants, Migrants and
Refugees. An Ethnological Approach’ (1998) 36 International Migration 107.
14 JS Berman, ‘No Place Like Home: Anti-Vietnamese Discrimination and Nationality in Cambodia’ (1996) 84 California Law
Review 817; S Ehrentraut, ‘Perpetually Temporary: Citizenship and Ethnic Vietnamese in Cambodia’ (2011) 34 Ethnic and
Racial Studies 779.
15 Nguyen & Sperfeldt; Ang & Chan (n 12).
16 Art. 4(2) of 1996 Law on Nationality.
17 Ehrentraut (n 14).
18 Nguyen & Sperfeldt (n 12).
19 ibid.
20 IRIN, ‘Ethnic Vietnamese in Cambodia Face Discrimination’ (2013) <http://www.irinnews.org/fr/report/98786/ethnicvietnamese-in-cambodia-face-discrimination> accessed 2 September 2015; Ang & Chan (n 12).
12
2