Part I. Introduction and Context
our second day [in Poland]. On the first day, a lorry with bread came from Poznan, that was
on Sunday. And then I wrote a letter to France… to my son: ‘Don’t write any more letters to
Germany. We are now in Zbaszyn.’”271
When Herschel Grynszpan learned of the expulsion and suffering of his family, he
revenged them by shooting Vom Rath.
Behind these events lies a story relating to statelessness. The expulsion of the Polish
Jews by the German authorities was caused by the Polish government announcing
in March 1938 that the passports of Polish citizens residing abroad for more than five
years would need to be revalidated, which had the “avowed aim of withdrawing such
documents from Jews living abroad”.272 The German government felt that these passport
regulations were directed towards Polish Jews living in Germany (and annexed Austria),
who would then remain stateless in the country.273 In the beginning of October 1938, the
Polish authorities communicated “that the decree would take effect on 30th October, the
deadline for passport revalidation”.274 In light thereof, the German Foreign Office decided
that the Polish Jews should be deported just before the new measures entered into force.
This, however, did not prevent a situation of chaos and statelessness between the German
and Polish border. Indeed, the Polish Jews were not considered to be citizens of Poland,
and were (largely) not admitted, but at the same time, the German authorities did not
consider them their problem and wanted them out of the country. They were without the
protection of a state – the sad results thereof were described above.
~
2.1. INTRODUCTION
Today, states are a self-evident part of our everyday lives and the order of the world
around us. In chapter 1, we saw that, even though often unnoticed, an individual
depends on states – and usually one state in particular – for undertaking straightforward
activities such as travelling for instance, that are often taken for granted. However,
the modern system of states of today remains imperfect, evidenced by the hundred
thousands of people who are stateless in Europe. The situation described above, dating
back to 1938, is therefore not exclusive for that time – many stateless people today are
also stuck in limbo. There is a significant gap in time between the beginning of the
20th century and today of course, and this chapter provides a bridge between the two,
271
272
273
274
52
Hannah Arendt, Eichmann in Jerusalem. A Report on the Banality of Evil (revised and enlarged edn,
The Viking Press 1964) 227–230. Here, he is referred to as Zindel.
Joseph Marcus, Social and Political History of the Jews in Poland 1919–1939 (De Gruyter Mouton 1983)
380.
Sybil Milton, ‘The Expulsion of the Polish Jews from Germany October 1938 to July 1939 (1984) 29 Leo
Baeck Institute Yearbook 169.
Ibid.
Intersentia
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents