2019
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
1(1)
custody or permission from their fathers to take them abroad, and without
possession of their legal documentation. Because of the timeline of migration
trends, the children that resulted from marriage migration to Taiwan are the oldest,
followed by those from Korea and then China. Currently, most of these children
remain in primary school, meaning the full scope of their legal problems may have
yet to reveal themselves. We believe this issue will continue to develop and
increase in severity as the children involved mature.
B
Data Collection and Findings
The research presented in this paper was conducted by a team of researchers in
and around Can Tho over a two-year period. 64 Through in-depth fieldwork in two
districts in the Can Tho region, our project was able to not only substantiate our
hypothesis that some of the children involved in these cases (especially groups 2,
3 and 4) face difficulties in accessing social rights within the Vietnamese legal and
administrative system, but also that they all potentially face future challenges in
asserting economic and political rights. Our research was carried out over three
stages from 2015–18 and included data collection with provincial and district level
officials, academic and non-governmental stakeholders and families of returned
children (rather than their mothers).
Interviews conducted with non-migrant stakeholders consisted of semistructured interviews intended to help gauge the extent of the problem, for which
no formal statistics currently exist. The existing statistics rely on migrant’s selfidentification with the Ministry of Justice and are thought to capture only a limited
number of women who have returned from marriage migration. The numbers
recorded by government officials are only collected from families who report
difficulties or apply for registration for themselves and/or the children. Because
there is no streamlined approach to data collection on this issue at either the
national or local level, each department within each province has different
statistics, meaning within any given district there are a variety of different numbers
to represent the same group of people. Because of this inconsistency in statistical
accuracy, it is impossible to know the total number of women who have returned
to the Delta with ‘bi-racial’ children as a result of marriage migration. 65 Although
several of our research subjects suggested that there could be ‘hundreds of
thousands’ of bi-racial children currently living permanently in southern Vietnam,
our research indicates that this number would be closer to somewhere in the
thousands.
Our survey captured information regarding the lived realities and legal status
of 45 families with bi-racial children within two districts. 66 These families
supported 206 bi-racial children living permanently in these districts. Based on
our scoping research, we estimate that this number reflects a significant fraction
of the total cases within these two districts; yet there are 126 districts in total within
the five provinces of the Mekong Delta region alone.
64
65
66
ibid. Primary data was collected and translated by Tran Thi Phung Ha: Ha (n 59).
We use the term ‘bi-racial’ here to refer to children born of a Vietnamese mother and either
Taiwanese, Korean or Chinese father.
In the vast majority of cases, interviews were conducted with grandparents of the children in
question. Migrant mothers often leave their children with grandparents in order to re-migrate
either internally in Vietnam or abroad.
80