5.6 ‘After the honeymoon’: Citizenship is not
the complete answer to statelessness but
holds significant weight and meaning for
stateless people
It is important to state that although obtaining citizenship means
somebody is no longer considered legally stateless, this does not
resolve many of the ongoing challenges a person may experience
by virtue of their previous statelessness status, such as family
separation, a sense of exclusion from their new community,
separation from one’s land, country and culture, socio economic
barriers stemming from their previous visa restrictions (such as a
prohibition on working, and therefore saving money for many years)
and ongoing mental health challenges.
“After I got my citizenship, I felt that after 30-something years, I
belonged somewhere. I can actually have a life without having
issues. Not without having any issues—there are always issues
for everyone—but without having the basic issues. But after the
honeymoon, you realise where you live now is still far from the
perfect world. So I feel happy. I feel I belong somewhere. At the same
time, I feel sad about being out of my own land. Yeah, there is a
mixture of happiness and growth in me. It reminds me of the season
of autumn. When you see the colourful leaves floating from the
branches to the ground. The beauty of walking through the colours
of these leaves, the crunch as you walk across them. But also the
sadness, because the leaves are leaving the tree. Winter will come,
but then it will be followed by Spring—there is hope coming.”
— Amir
The unexpected challenges that can continue once a stateless
person finally obtains some form of legal certainty (such as a visa,
permanent residency or citizenship) were noted by members of the
mental health profession.
“There’s almost like a honeymoon period after they get their visa,
but then they realise that isn’t actually the fix to all their problems.
They still then are starting their life in Australia, all those lost years,
all that trauma then can often—you know, they’re finally able to
almost land and then all the trauma symptoms that they’ve kept at
bay and they’ve been in fight or flight, they crash.”
— Psychologist, Torture and Trauma Rehabilitation Service
The powerful role, however, that citizenship can play in relation
to a stateless person’s sense of ‘belonging’ in Australia was also
highlighted by mental health professionals.
“Citizenship is very significant obviously for a lot of people of
refugee backgrounds, getting the passport enabling them to travel,
et cetera. But particularly for stateless people, its recognition, it’s
belonging to a community which they’ve never had.”
— Mental Health Worker
The significance of citizenship was emphasised consistently in many
of the interviews we conducted with stateless people for this Project.
“(Obtaining citizenship) means I’ve finally cracked it. It’s almost felt
like this quest that I’ve been on for as long as I could remember…
For me, citizenship is critical. And forget the legal part of it; to be
called a citizen of a country, I mean, that’s something I’ve always
wanted. I wanted to belong somewhere…
Oh, I can’t even describe what (obtaining Australian citizenship)
is going to be like. It’s going to be 33 years in the making, and lots
of good people tried their best and unfortunately they’re not here
anymore to celebrate it. It’s going to feel, I think, overwhelming.
Because I feel I’ll be the one receiving that citizenship, or that
certificate, but that’s the combination or the accumulation of the
effort of so many amazing people—including my family—over 30
years, three decades, that helped me get to this point. So really, it
should be around 30 people standing on that stage receiving that,
with me, but I’ll try to make the best out of it and make the best out
of this opportunity, because a lot of people paid a great price for
me to get here.”
— Fadi
This extended to the sense of relief stateless parents reported
feeling by seeing their children become Australian citizens, even
in situations where they were unable to access any pathway to
naturalisation for themselves.
“When my youngest child got Australian citizenship I felt like
crying. I am so happy. I don’t believe it really. I feel relief. All my life
hardships are worth it to see my son okay. After more than a decade
of limbo here, that is enough. Enough time to wait.”
— Kareem*
“Both our children have citizenship. I can’t tell you how happy this
makes me feel. So very happy for the kids and what this means for
their future. When I came here we had nothing. We are happy for
the kids because their life is here now. They are Australian.”
— Yasmin*
Understanding Statelessness in Australia | Peter McMullin Centre on Statelessness 67
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents