The challenges of immigration detention were also highlighted by
stateless participants who recalled being detained as children.
“I arrived in Australia in 2013, when I was 10. I arrived by boat with
my siblings and parents. Unfortunately, I remember it all very well,
especially the detention centre in Darwin where we were held. It all
felt very foreign—I felt like an alien. We weren’t referred to by name.
We were referred to by numbers.”
— Asma
Family separation between detention centres around Australia
and between Australia was also observed as traumatic for parents
and children.
“My son became very unwell on the boat journey. As soon as we got
off the boat at Christmas Island he was taken to hospital. My wife
was also very unwell, she was bleeding and we were worried about
the baby. We told the guards and they dismissed her – said ‘just go
have a lie down.’ Then the next day without notice, they came and
took her. Took her away from me and the children, didn’t tell us
where she was going or why. Didn’t tell us when she would be back.
They didn’t tell her either – she didn’t know she was going to be taken
to hospital. She begged to take our little one – our youngest child.
But they said no.
They took her to Darwin – alone. They left us behind. She was all
alone, in a new country, without us, unsure if her baby had survived.
We didn’t know where Darwin was, how far, when we would see
her again. I was left in detention on Christmas Island – one son
in hospital, my other children crying for their mother. They didn’t
understand what was happening – how could they? Our youngest
daughter was two at the time. Still in nappies. She needed her mum.”
— Kareem*
The ongoing trauma of parents seeing their children in immigration
was observed to be strongly felt in stateless parents interviewed for
this research.
“Detention in Darwin with a young child and a newborn was very
hard... My daughter’s earliest memories are of this time. Sometimes
she will say to me, “I grew up in a detention centre.”
— Yasmin*
Family separation between detention centres in Australia and
offshore facilities was also observed to be highly traumatic for
stateless people, with immediate family members being classified
by the Australian government as ‘single adult men’ and transferred
offshore accordingly, despite arriving within a family unit.
“My brother came with us. When we arrived, he was taken to Nauru.
The guards said he was a single man so must go to Nauru. They
wouldn’t recognise that he was part of our family. Every day I would
ask the guards on Christmas Island – ‘Where is he? Where is my
brother?’ They told me nothing.”
The protracted periods of uncertainty imposed on stateless people
by the existing migration legal and policy framework was observed
by health professionals as negatively impacting the mental health of
stateless people in Australia.
“The protracted nature of those applications, the constant or
the protracted time they spend in limbo, not knowing what’s
happening. That brings about a whole other set of health
complexities around mental health and access to health services.”
— Refugee Health Worker
Mental health professionals interviewed for this Project spoke to
the fact that although stateless people might be physically safe
in Australia (compared to trauma experienced in their countries
of origin or in transit to Australia) this does not mean that they
experience psychologically safety.
“These clients often, even if they’re physically safe in Australia,
they’re not living in necessarily a psychologically safe state with
the uncertainty, the worry for the future, the re-experiencing of the
trauma that they’re going through, they’re often in fight or flight,
so (treatment) is about safety, stabilisation, regulation, emotional
regulation, getting them a bit more involved in the community,
whether that’s their community or just the community in general.”
— Psychologist, Torture and Trauma Rehabilitation Service
Feelings of psychological unsafety in Australia, despite being
physically safe from the persecution or trauma they may have
experienced prior to their arrival was also observed in the
experiences of stateless people we spoke to for this study. One
participant identified a lack of knowledge as to the experience of
stateless refugees by the medical profession as an exacerbating
cause of mental health issues within the community.
“When you get to a safer place, people think your problems are over.
They’re not. We have family back home who are constantly being
killed, trying to escape, and pleading for help. We feel helpless,
unable to do anything. We’re already struggling ourselves here.
The lack of awareness about mental health when it comes to
refugees and their health being neglected is huge. Every time I go
to a doctor, I’m always gaslighted. When I have issues I bring up,
they’re like, “It’s fine. Just drink water. Just take this medication.
Don’t worry about it. You’re still young.”
I had one doctor who said to me, to my face. “You’re in Australia.
Why are you depressed?” Despite him knowing. Despite him
knowing I’m a Rohingya and all I have experienced. I have a long,
long history of persecution in my family.
I’ve completely given up on going to the doctors.”
— Asma
— Kareem*
Understanding Statelessness in Australia | Peter McMullin Centre on Statelessness 63
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents