5.2.1 Family separation and impact on family life
“It’s been more than ten years since I was with my family. I can’t
bear to think about it. It is too painful to talk about…
My youngest child was a few months old when I first left to come
to Australia. Now she is almost 11. My son is a teenager.
I have missed their childhoods waiting on a better life for us all
in Australia.”
— Nasir*
Without opportunities to study, work, or buy a home, stateless
people reported being reluctant to start families or put down roots.
In some cases, anxieties experienced by stateless people about their
ability to settle and build a life in Australia mirrored their experience
in their country of origin.
“My dream is to buy a home for my family. For my family to live
in safety. I’ve been here for ten years now and I still don’t have
permanent protection. It is a long time.”
— Hassan*
The uncertainty imposed on stateless people by the existing
migration legal and policy framework was observed by lawyers as
impeding their client’s ability to build a life in Australia.
“... it often leads to a result that clients who are unable to prove
their identities are just stuck, some can’t be let out of detention for
years, some are let out on bridging visas with very limited ability
to settle, limited ability to technically start a life at all, in all the
ways that word means. They’re reluctant to start families, they’re
reluctant to build any sort of life for themselves after fleeing a
certain country because they’re not sure if they’re able to settle.”
“My main hope is to bring my family here to Australia. Over the
years I’ve talked to my wife and kids. I try and be strong. I tell them,
slowly change will come, there is a process. As soon as I can get
the permanent visa, I will sponsor them. Thinking of this keeps us
going, it gives us hope. The idea of being together again makes us
happy. I want to be with my family. Families belong together.”
— Nasir*
“(For) family reunification, everything’s just harder and longer,
trying to obtain documents for identity for family members if
they’re also stateless. And ImmiCards need to be issued. That takes
a really long time. They’re just at another disadvantage in their life,
trying to reunite family.”
— Carina Ford, Australian Legal Practitioner, Carina Ford Immigration Lawyers
Family separation was further observed to have a serious and
detrimental impact on stateless people in Australia by those who
work closely with them.
“Oh, they’re so, so sad, and then, often their families are stuck in
really awful situations, either in country, or like the poor Rohingyas
in Cox’s Bazaar in Bangladesh—their families are stuck in these
horrible situations, and all they want to do is bring them here, and
they can’t, and they can’t visit them, and it’s just miserable—awful.”
— Natalie Young, Australian Legal Practitioner, Victoria Legal Aid.
— Australian Legal Practitioner
Family separation, and prohibitions on the ability to sponsor loved
ones to come to Australia was observed to have a devastating impact
on stateless people interviewed for this study.
“My mother and siblings are in a refugee camp. One is in
Bangladesh, some are in Thailand. I’m desperate to visit my
mother. She is getting very old now. But I’m not allowed to travel. I
haven’t been able to contact her since I was in detention in 2014.
I’m worried about her, I need to see her.”
— Hassan, stateless father
Family reunion under Australia’s existing legal framework was
identified as particularly challenging for stateless people. This is
particularly the case where parents may be separated from children
(see, for example, Nasir’s* story in Appendix: Stories of Statelessness
in Australia).
Understanding Statelessness in Australia | Peter McMullin Centre on Statelessness 61
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents