One stateless participant interviewed found that despite being allowed
to work, it was practically easier to gain the work experience and build
the professional relationships he needed by volunteering, given the
short-term nature of his temporary visas made it too hard to seek
employment.
“Eventually I was given a Bridging Visa. I was allowed to work and
a kind man took me on as a mechanical volunteer. He helped me
learn English. I now work as a machine operator. The Bridging Visa
was hard though, because it would expire all the time, every six
months. So even though I could work, it was easier to volunteer at
the mechanics.”
— Hassan*
For one participant, discrimination in seeking employment was
compounded by both his disability and statelessness.
“In addition to studying, I wanted to work. I applied for 117 jobs.
I went to over 50 interviews. I knew the issue was not me. The
main issue was unconscious bias. You step into the interview,
and the interviewee would say, “Wow.” They would say amongst
themselves, “If I was blind, I wouldn’t be able to do this job.”
Perhaps it wasn’t always out loud, but they would say that in their
head. When I was in the interview, they focused on my disability
rather than my ability to do the job.”
— Amir
For another stateless person interviewed, even volunteering proved
too difficult, due to a lack of documentation and excessive regulations
placed on her by the Department of Immigration.
“I’m not allowed to work. It’s also hard for me to volunteer—I want
to be useful and do something with my time. I tried volunteering
for a large charity, but I couldn’t get a police check because I don’t
have enough documents. I also need to get permission from my case
manager to volunteer. I feel like they control every aspect of my life.”
— Nur*
Stateless participants interviewed for this research spoke strongly
about their desire to work to support themselves, so as not to be
reliant on government welfare.
want; no-one wants to be a liability and feel useless….
It just allows me to keep my dignity, in a nutshell. And for someone
like me—maybe it’s a cultural background, I’m not sure—when
you take that away from me, you might as well kill me. I mean, the
worst periods of my life were when I couldn’t provide for my family,
when I couldn’t take care of my mother, where I just felt useless as
a man. So giving me that power back is priceless. It’s almost you’ve
given me a second lease on life.”
— Fadi
By contrast, another stateless participant spoke of her confusion
regarding her work ethic and contribution to the Australian economy
not allowing her to in turn, fully integrate into the Australian
community due to restrictions on her visa.
“I had such limited options. Here I was, working, paying taxes, and
yet the only options for me was to apply for a refugee protection
visa. I suspect many others walk this path too. There was no other
option for me, no other pathway available. I expected to have more
rights, especially given how I’m contributing to the economy. I’m
not a burden on the government. I’d expect that I’d be allowed to
visit my sisters in other safe parts of the world, and come back to
my job, my life here.”
— Amira*
Overall, the desire to work, to contribute, and the dignity that comes
from that was a strong theme across interviews.
“I look at all my friends from the community. They become
workaholics because they identify with that and feel they need
to appreciate this country. But as soon as they are not working,
their mental health gets worse because they haven’t got their visa
situation sorted. And they feel their life is in limbo. It’s kind of a
journey where you never know where you are.”
— Amir
5.1.5 Exclusion from belonging
“The hardest part is that Myanmar says we don’t belong. I come
here and the Australian government say slowly, slowly, step-bystep. So where do I go? What can I do? No country says I belong.”
“I don’t want to be a liability. I’ve been taking care of myself and my
mother since I was 16; I’ve been paying the bills and putting food on
the table. So the last thing I want is to come to this country and sit on
government relief, and rely on them to feed me and feel useless. I’ve
always hated feeling useless….
— Nasir*
…(working after arrival in Australia) allowed me to keep my
pride, and keep my dignity. I know sometimes they speak about it
negatively, but I feel proud that I came here with a job, that from day
one I’m earning and paying my taxes and I’m contributing, and I’m
being productive. It’s just so empowering, I cannot tell you. And if you
ask every single refugee, or person who’s struggling, that’s what they
“Just the personal, or human, experience of people who are coming
to Australia, they’ve not been accepted by any country, and then
this next country is not accepting them; it’s a very emotional thing
for a lot of my clients, if not every practitioner’s client.”
58 Peter McMullin Centre on Statelessness | Understanding Statelessness in Australia
Both stateless people and stakeholders interviewed for this Report
spoke to the devastation of stateless people fleeing a place where
they were not accepted, only to experience exclusion in Australia.
— Australian Legal Practitioner
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents