Thus, upon subdivision of the 1,300 acres, Mnisi would be able to deal with his portion in any manner that he deems fit. He could sell it to a third party, lease it or use
the land as security for a loan as he holds an ID. By contrast, as Shauku is not recognized as a citizen, he would not be able to deal in the land, unless the president
waives the citizenship requirement. 212
Piet and Dlamini describe the challenges persons at risk of statelessness face in relation to owning immovable property such as land:
I cannot own my own shamba (farm). People are reluctant to sell their land to us. [Maybe] they want
us to bribe them. 213
We live like visitors yet we have been in [Kenya] for over 30 years. The farms were divided and I paid for
a plot, but I do not have a title deed as I do not have an ID. 214
When asked what his future hopes and aspirations were, Todil stated: to own ‘a farm
as I am now old and would like to stay on a farm with my partner’. 215 Eleven (16%) of
the persons at risk of statelessness that were interviewed expressed concerns with
Kenya’s land ownership and transfer system. Just over one-third (8; 24%) of the officials who participated in this study also criticized this regime. For persons at risk
of statelessness the situation is quite serious. In the first place, some farmers were
forced to rent land. 216 While through this option these individuals may be able to
continue farming, and thereby earn an income, it is notideal in the sense that renting is not a permanent solution. If the owner decides not to renew the agreement,
there is very little a tenant could do, provided adequate notice has been given. Further, unlike Mnisi, those who are stateless cannot offer their land as security in order
to obtain loans from banks and micro-finance institutions. As mentioned earlier, the
lack of access to external financial support has serious consequences for the lives and
livelihoods of persons at risk of statelessness. Moreover, being deprived of the right
to own property prohibits individuals from engaging in certain trades such as land
buying and selling in their own names.
The situation is a bit different for those wishing to bequeath their property, including
agricultural land. Under the terms of the Law of Succession Act (1981) every person
is eligible to make a will, as long as he or she meets certain age and psychological requirements. 217 Notably, there is no citizenship test to be met. Thus, if Shauku’s father
Section 24 of the Land Control Act.
Interview with Piet, Coast Province, 15 September 2009.
214
Interview with Dlamini, Coast Province, 14 September 2009.
215
Interview with Todil, Coast Province, 15 September 2009.
216
Interview with Sada, Coast Province, 15 September 2009; Interview with Piet, Coast Province, 19
September 2009.
217
See section 5 of the Law of Succession Act (‘any person who is of sound mind and not a minor may
dispose of all or part of his free property by will’). But, according to Thomas, one of the challenges
facing
212
213
36
OUT OF THE SHADOWS TOWARDS ENSURING THE RIGHTS OF STATELESS PERSONS AND PERSONS AT RISK OF STATELESSNESS IN KENYA
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents