This year, for the first time, we have accounted
for three types of returnees from Pakistan and
Iran who found themselves in a situation of
internal displacement once (back) in Afghanistan.
We included 44,197 Afghans who were deported
or voluntarily returned from Iran based on input
from our sources in Afghanistan, including UN
OCHA. This figure, approximately 10 per cent of
the returns from Iran, is predominantly composed
of young men who left Afghanistan in search of
work and were considered displaced and in need
of humanitarian assistance upon their return.
We also included 285,951 individuals, who are
part of a significant wave of returns from Pakistan. UNHCR estimates 48 per cent of returning
refugees were not able to return to their place
of origin. These people therefore fit the government’s definition of an internally displaced
person.
Finally, we have included a caseload of 22,559
undocumented Afghans who were forcibly
deported from Pakistan back to Afghanistan.
Given the involuntary nature of the return and
the humanitarian needs of these individuals once
back in Afghanistan, we consider them to be in
a situation of internal displacement.
Births and deaths in displacement
We only account for births and deaths in displacement when our partners provide data. Given the
shortage of disaggregated data and the fact that
IDPs’ fertility and mortality rates may not correspond with national figures, we do not try to
extrapolate births and deaths in displacement
from national demographic data.
Depending on the scale and duration of displacement, the lack of primary data on these flows can
represent a potentially significant blind spot. In
protracted crises such as Macedonia’s, reported
changes in the size of the displaced population
may depend more on demographic trends than
on returns, local integration and settlement elsewhere, given the lack of progress in these areas.
Total number of IDPs
The inflows and outflows described above all
influence the total number or “stock” of IDPs at a
given moment in time – 31 December 2016 in the
case of this report. We estimate the number of
IDPs at the end of the year by triangulating data
reported from one or more sources with a mathematically derived estimate based on the “flow”
data available on new displacement, returns, local
integration, settlement elsewhere, cross-border
flight and births and deaths in displacement.
We arrive at the total number of IDPs as of 31
December 2016 by taking the total at the end
of 2015 and adding or subtracting flow data as
follows:
Total number of IDPsDec 2016 =
Total number of IDPsDec 2015
+ [Births2016 + new displacement2016]
– [Returns2016 + settlement elsewhere2016 +
local integration2016 + cross-border flight2016
+ deaths2016]
The equation is technically incomplete because
it does not take into account the “counterflows”
represented by failed returns, local integration
and settlement elsewhere, or cross-border
returns into displacement. Given, however, that
data is not collected and these phenomena
are accounted for as new rather than repeated
displacement, the equation serves its purpose.
In reality, the lack of coverage of the components
of our data model and the way outflow data is
aggregated mean the actual equation for most
countries is often simply:
Total number of IDPsDec 2016 =
Total number of IDPsDec 2015
+ New displacement2016
– Returns2016
The mathematical formula for estimating the
stock of IDPs is at best a modelled approximation.
We compare this with the data we obtain from
our sources, and they do not always correspond.
There are number of reasons for this:
|| The initial value – the estimate for the end of
the previous year – is incorrect and needs to
be revised. This occurs in Afghanistan, among
other countries, due to the length of time it
takes to verify displacement figures.
|| New displacement includes repeated displacement: This is the case every year in countries
such as DRC or South Sudan, where pendular
displacement – in which IDPs “commute”
back and forth between their places of refuge
and origin, often to tend to their land – generates higher numbers of displacements that
often relate to the same people.
METHODOLOGICAL ANNEX
99
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents