Unit 5 [core unit]
Preventing statelessness (2):
Nationality, discrimination and statelessness
Summary
This unit looks at the role that
discrimination can play in the
creation and perpetuation of
statelessness. The two main issues
considered are discrimination on the
grounds of gender and discrimination
against ethnic, religious or linguistic
minorities. The unit discusses the
existence of, and reasoning behind,
nationality laws that discriminate on
the basis of gender. It looks at the
increased vulnerability of women
to statelessness as a result of
changes to their nationality status
through marriage or divorce and the
heightened risk of statelessness
among children where nationality
laws limit the ability of women to
transmit their nationality to their
children. The approach taken to
gender and nationality in the 1961
Convention on the Reduction of
Statelessness is identified. Students
then look at the role of human rights
law and instruments such as ICCPR,
CEDAW and the Convention on
the Nationality of Married Women
in tackling gender discrimination in
the context of nationality attribution.
The content and scope of these
provisions are discussed, including
through consideration of a number of
reports, statements and conclusions
by relevant bodies such as the
CEDAW Committee.
Thereafter, the vulnerability of
ethnic, religious and linguistic
minority groups to deprivation or
denial of nationality is discussed
and illustrated through examples
that show the different ways in
Learning objectives
•
Describe the role that discrimination can play in creating
and perpetuating statelessness.
•
Explain why women may find themselves at risk of
statelessness and how gender discrimination in nationality
law can heighten the threat of statelessness among
children.
•
Discuss the value of the human rights instruments for
the prevention of statelessness in the context of gender
discrimination.
28 A Guide to Teaching on Statelessness
which discrimination may influence
law or practice. The provision
of the 1961 Convention on the
Reduction of Statelessness that
addresses discriminatory deprivation
of nationality is considered before
relevant human rights norms,
including CERD, resolutions of the
Human Rights Council, the former
Commission on Human Rights, and
regional instruments are discussed.
Students are also familiarised with
the decision of the Inter-American
Court on Human Rights in the Case
of Yean and Bosico v. Dominican
Republic – the context of and details
of this case can also be used as the
focal point for discussing this issue,
with students basing the investigation
of relevant international norms
around this case study.
•
Explain the ways in which minority groups may find
themselves at risk of statelessness.
•
Discuss the value of the 1961 Convention on the
Reduction of Statelessness for the prevention of
statelessness in the context of discrimination against
minorities.
•
Identify and discuss other relevant international
standards for the avoidance of statelessness in the context
of discrimination against minorities.