RISING STATELESSNESS DUE TO DISAPPEARING
ISLAND STATES: DOES THE CURRENT STATUS OF
INTERNATIONAL LAW OFFER SUFFICIENT
PROTECTION?
MARIJA DOBRIĆ *
Scientific prognoses have shown that by the year 2100, several low-lying island states such as
Tuvalu and Kiribati will disappear due to rising sea levels. The submergence of whole territories
will have consequences including the displacement of a huge number of islanders. In that context,
the question of how to protect their human rights in their future host states is of great importance.
In fact, their human rights protection will most likely prove even more difficult if disappearing
island states are considered to have lost statehood. Without the nationality of any state, those
displaced islanders will be stateless under international law. In this article, the author assesses
whether displaced island populations are sufficiently protected by existing international law norms
or whether the international community is called upon to create new rules addressing these future
challenges.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I
II
III
IV
V
VI
Introduction............................................................................................................. 42
Statelessness — The Definition Dilemma .............................................................. 45
The Importance of Having a Nationality ................................................................ 47
The Right to Nationality ......................................................................................... 49
Loss of Nationality on the Example of Disappearing Island States ........................ 52
A Continuing Statehood of Disappearing Island States?................................ 53
B De Lege Lata Protection Possibilities for an Externally Displaced
Island Population ........................................................................................ 58
1
The 1954 and 1961 Statelessness Conventions .............................. 58
2
Human Rights Treaties (ICCPR and ICESCR) .............................. 63
3
The Refugee Convention ................................................................ 64
Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 67
I
INTRODUCTION
As of today, many millions of people around the world are stateless. 1 Despite that
large number, the protection regimes under international law that are currently in
place fail to safeguard their human rights adequately. The most recent flight of the
stateless Rohingya people from the territory of Myanmar and its wide coverage in
*
1
Marija Dobrić was a Researcher and Lecturer at the Section for International Law and
International Human Rights Law at the Bundeswehr University Munich before taking up her
current position as a Judicial Clerk at the Higher Regional Court of Vienna.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, ‘Statelessness around the World’,
<http://www.unhcr.org/statelessness-around-the-world.html>.