2019
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
1(2)
Figure 2: A Convener’s visit to a Lahu household.
ETHNOGRAPHIC ACCOUNT TWO
The second stop on our field visit was a small stateless Hmong community, whose
life story complicates existing literature on the relationship between the Hmong
and the Thai state and exemplifies state illegibility. During the Cold War, the Thai
army and the United States of America Central Intelligence Agency recruited the
Hmong communities to fight against the communist insurgents along the Thai–
Laos borders through programmes that would ensure both legibility and loyalty to
the state such as permanent settlement, military training and citizenship
conferral. 89 These Hmong are officially referred to by the Thai state as ‘the Hmong
of Wat Thamkrabok’ 90 (ม้งในที่พกั สงฆ์ถ้ าํ กระบอก), and also sometimes as ‘the Hmong
who have contributed to Thailand’ (ม้งทําคุณประโยชน์). However, more than 40 years
have passed and this family still is without the promised citizenship, affecting the
lives of subsequent generations. A man in his 50s, whose father was part of the
89
90
John McKinnon and Bernard Vienne, Hill Tribes Today: Problems in Change (White LotusOrstom 1989), cited in Flaim (n 14) 154–5; See also William Leary, ‘CIA Air Operations in
Laos, 1955–1974: Supporting the “Secret War”’, Central Intelligence Agency (Web Page, 14
April
2007)
<https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intelligence/csipublications/csi-studies/studies/winter99-00/art7.html>.
Wat Thamkrabok is a Thai Buddhist temple where many Hmong took refuge. Ian Baird
explores the relationship between the temple and the Hmong people in details in Ian G Baird
‘The Monks and the Hmong: The Special Relationship between the Chao Fa and the Tham
Krabok Buddhist Temple in Saraburi Province, Thailand’ in Vladimir Tikhonov and Torkel
Brekke (eds), Buddhism and Violence: Militarism and Buddhism in Modern Asia (Routledge
2013).
228