ADDRESSING STATELESSNESS THROUGH THE RULE OF LAW
Equality under the law and
non-discrimination
Discrimination and inequality are
both causes and consequences of
statelessness. Millions of people are
left stateless due to discriminatory
deprivation of nationality on the
basis of ethnicity or religion and
as a consequence of formal or
informal policies and practices that
have a disproportionate impact on
certain groups.18 A notable example
of statelessness as a result of
discrimination can be found in Myanmar,
where the ethnic and religious minority
Rohingya have been deprived of their
right to a legal identity for decades.
Other stateless populations affected
by discriminatory laws and policies
include persons of Haitian descent in
the Dominican Republic, ethnic Kurds
in Syria, and Romani populations
in Europe. Statelessness often
exacerbates the marginalisation and
exclusion that minorities may face,
further limiting their access to rights
and services, and deepening their sense
of being outsiders and not belonging.
The rule of law requires measures to
ensure adherence to the principles of
equality before the law and fairness
in the application of the law. All
persons subject to the jurisdiction of
any State, regardless of legal status,
are in principle equal before the law
and have equal protection under the
law. States have a positive obligation
to ensure that stateless persons
within their jurisdiction are protected
against such rights violations and are
able to access justice mechanisms.
The adoption of just and equitable
legislative measures, as well as the
elimination of discriminatory laws,
helps prevent rights violations and
promotes the realisation of rights more
broadly. International and regional
law, international jurisprudence,
and treaty body conclusions and
recommendations, as well as States’
commitments to the 2030 Agenda,
require States to refrain from arbitrarily
depriving anyone of nationality,19
discriminating against individuals or
groups in the application of nationality
laws, policies, and procedures, or
discriminating against stateless
persons due to their lack of citizenship.
Box 2: Reforming nationality laws in Morocco
The reform of discriminatory laws, policies, and procedures helps prevent and resolve statelessness and has a direct
impact on the number of stateless persons in a country. This can be seen in countries that have taken steps to remove
gender discrimination from their nationality laws such as Morocco.20 In March 2007, Morocco passed a bill amending
the Nationality Code, granting Moroccan women the same rights as those enjoyed by men to confer nationality on their
children, with retroactive effect.21 The new provision provides that a child born to a Moroccan father, or a Moroccan
mother is Moroccan. In 2008, Morocco lifted its reservation to Article 9(2) of the Convention on the Elimination of All
Forms of Discrimination Against Women.22 At the end of December 2011, the number of children born to Moroccan
mothers and foreign fathers who had been able to obtain Moroccan nationality since the entry into force of the
Nationality Code had reached 32,571. In 2018 alone, the number was 33,587.
Compliance with international
human rights norms and
standards
The right to nationality can be found
in a number of major human rights
instruments, starting with Article 15
of the Universal Declaration of Human
Rights, with a particular emphasis
placed on the right of every child to
acquire a nationality.23 Unfortunately,
laws and policies which deprive children
of nationality on a discriminatory or
arbitrary basis, as well as laws that fail
to include crucial safeguards to prevent
statelessness from occurring during
childhood and later in life mean that in
many countries the right to nationality
is an obligation that is often breached.
For example, apart from countries that
8
subscribe to a jus soli regime under
which children born on the territory of
a State acquire the nationality of that
State simply as a result of being born
there, States must enact safeguards
so that children who are not able to
acquire nationality from their parents
are not left stateless. This would be the
case, for example, for children born to
two stateless parents, or in the case
of children left abandoned and whose
parents are unknown.
In his report ‘In larger freedom:
Towards development, security and
human rights for all,’ the UN SecretaryGeneral noted that “…[a]ll human
beings have the right to be treated with
dignity and respect”.24 Such dignity and
respect are afforded to people through
the enjoyment of all human rights
and are protected through the rule
of law. The backbone of the freedom
to live in dignity is the international
human rights law framework, together
with international humanitarian
law, international criminal law, and
international refugee law.
While it is in principle for each State to
determine under its own law who are
its nationals, States are also required to
comply with international human rights
law concerning the granting and loss of
nationality, which puts significant limits
on State discretion in this respect.25 The
consistent application of international
standards on statelessness is essential
to end statelessness. Accession to
international and regional conventions