ADDRESSING STATELESSNESS THROUGH THE RULE OF LAW
1. INTRODUCTION
© Brian Sokol, UNHCR 2014:
Yulin, 25, and her children are stateless in the Dominican Republic. She says: “I feel Dominican because it’s the only
place I’ve ever lived. I was born here and at the time I was born the constitution said that anyone born here is
a Dominican.”
In this issue brief, the International
Development Law Organization (IDLO)
and UNHCR address the intricate links
between statelessness, the rule of law
and sustainable development. Ensuring
adherence to the rule of law is critical
to resolving existing situations of
statelessness and to preventing new
situations from arising. The principle
of the rule of law, as embedded
in international human rights
instruments,1 is key to the UN 2030
Agenda for Sustainable Development
(2030 Agenda), with its call for legal
and institutional reforms, protection of
rights, and legal empowerment of the
most vulnerable and excluded.
In a world order based on State
sovereignty, an individual’s legal
identity is expressed through the legal
bond of nationality. Statelessness (i.e.,
not being considered as a national
4
by any State under the operation of
its law) is therefore an anomaly and
undermines the rule of law 2 due to
both its causes and consequences.
It often arises from discrimination
and arbitrary laws or practices and
prevents stateless persons from
enjoying full equality under the law in
any country. Statelessness results in
widespread denial of human rights and
it undermines the universal human
right to a nationality.3 Statelessness
can inflict a lifetime of hardship,
extend across generations, and plunge
whole communities into situations
of protracted humanitarian crisis.
Statelessness has the potential to
lead to underdevelopment and to
exacerbate underprivilege, exclusion
and marginalisation that are often
the hallmarks of conflict and
displacement.
The issue brief stresses that, by
upholding the rule of law, States can
unlock lasting solutions to the anomaly
of statelessness and dramatically
improve the lives and futures of
stateless people and the societies in
which they live. It concludes with a set
of recommendations for policymakers,
focusing on:
1. Equality before the law and nondiscrimination
2. Compliance with international
human rights norms and standards
3. Legal empowerment and access to
justice
4. Inclusive and participatory system
of governance