17. The legal and policy framework related to the right to a nationality, and the rights of
stateless persons in Ireland has, on paper, some positive aspects. Nationality law
provides for accelerated naturalisation of stateless persons and the waiver of fees.
However, as will be discussed in para. 33-35, practical challenges exist in relation to
facilitated naturalisation due to the lack of a statelessness determination procedure.
Although statelessness may be examined in the context of other administrative
procedures, determination of statelessness is not the explicit objective of any of these
procedures, and they do not lead to adequate protection and rights under the 1954
Convention.
18. Further, national law does not contain a definition of a stateless person, and the national
legal framework does not allow for direct application of the 1954 Convention definition
without incorporation into domestic law.
19. There are some safeguards to ensure children’s right to a nationality in Ireland, but there
are gaps in law and practice for some children born stateless on the territory. Further, it
is unclear how a child’s nationality may be determined if they are not entitled to apply
for an Irish passport, resulting in a risk of statelessness in some cases.23
20. International law prohibits the arbitrary deprivation of nationality, as well as nationality
deprivation which is discriminatory or results in statelessness. As this submission will
elaborate, nationality deprivation practices in Ireland lack adequate safeguards in this
regard.
21. International law also prohibits arbitrary detention. Without adequate safeguards,
stateless people can be at particular risk of arbitrary immigration detention. 24
Immigration detention is generally the exception rather than the norm in Ireland.
Stateless people are not routinely detained, but there are some gaps in legal protections
against their arbitrary detention. For example, there is no requirement for a country of
removal to be identified in deportation orders and statelessness is not proactively
considered in decisions to detain. The law does not explicitly provide that detention
should only be used as a measure of last resort after all alternatives have been
exhausted and legal aid is not guaranteed. People released from immigration detention
are not issued with identification documents nor do they have specific rights unless they
have applied for international protection.
Issue 1: The rights of stateless persons and access to a
nationality
Identification and determination of statelessness
22. Identifying stateless people in the country is a necessary first step to providing them a
secure legal status, and protecting and ensuring their enjoyment of basic human rights.
Without early identification and formal determination of statelessness, stateless
persons cannot enjoy their rights under human rights treaties and the 1954 Convention,
23
See paragraphs 37-41 below.
European Network on Statelessness, Protecting Stateless Persons from Arbitrary Detention: An Agenda for Change, 2017:
https://www.statelessness.eu/sites/www.statelessness.eu/files/attachments/resources/ENS_LockeInLimbo_Detention_Agend
a_online.pdf; European Network on Statelessness, Protecting Stateless Persons from Arbitrary Detention: A regional toolkit for
practitioners, 2017: https://www.statelessness.eu/sites/www.statelessness.eu/files/ENS_Detention_Toolkit.pdf.
24
5