2020
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
2(1)
how to prevent modern slavery in the future. 2 Effective measurement of modern
slavery is the cornerstone of evidence-based policy making in our field and can
have a similarly powerful impact on statelessness research. This symposium on
the challenges, solutions and best practices of measurement in modern slavery —
and how it can inform statelessness research — is a critical opportunity to ensure
that all stakeholders feel empowered to interpret and use our collective findings.
II
STATELESSNESS IN THE AMERICAS AND THE RISK OF EXPLOITATION AND
MODERN SLAVERY
Statelessness increases risk of modern slavery and presents an opportunity for a
shared research agenda, particularly in the Americas. Despite increased media
coverage of modern slavery throughout the region, statelessness might not be the
first issue that we consider when we think of the Americas. 3 However, over the
past six years, the vulnerabilities to statelessness resulting from the Venezuelan
crisis and the citizenship stripping of Dominicans of Haitian descent have
propelled the Americas into prominent focus in statelessness discussions. 4
Importantly, the Americas remains a region with strong domestic legislative
precedent for citizenship provisions and, therefore, a potential opportunity for
meaningful action to address statelessness and its inherent risk of exploitation. 5
Multiple components of the GSI Global Vulnerability Model correspond to the
risks that stateless persons face in the Americas and around the world, including
adverse effects from governance issues, lack of basic needs, inequality,
membership in disenfranchised groups and effects of conflict, including risk of
internal displacement. 6 Challenges in measuring statelessness powerfully overlap
with challenges in measuring modern slavery as an important focal point for
research and motivating political action in both fields. In particular, risk of
exploitation and modern slavery among stateless populations warrants further
consideration. These intersecting research interests can be pursued in the Americas
region through the following opportunities for a joint research agenda on
statelessness and modern slavery.
A
De Jure Statelessness of Dominicans of Haitian-Descent and Risk of
Exploitation and Modern Slavery
De jure stateless persons, those who are unable to invoke the protection of any
state, are the most commonly understood form of statelessness under the United
2
3
4
5
6
Global Slavery Index (Report, Walk Free Foundation 2018) <globalslaveryindex.org>
(‘GSI’).
Laura Van Waas, Amal de Chickera and Zahra Albarazi, ‘The World’s Stateless: A New
Report on Why Size Does and Does Not Matter’, European Network on Statelessness (Blog
Post, 15 December 2014) <https://www.statelessness.eu/blog/world%E2%80%99s-statelessnew-report-why-size-does-and-doesn%E2%80%99t-matter>.
The World’s Stateless: Deprivation of Nationality (Report, Instute on Statelessness and
Inclusion
March
2020)
65–68
(‘The
World’s
Stateless’)
<https://www.institutesi.org/resources/worlds-stateless-2020>.
ibid 55.
Minderoo Foundation, ‘2018 Methodology: Vulnerability’, Global Slavery Index (Web Page,
2018) <https://www.globalslaveryindex.org/2018/methodology/vulnerability/>; GSI (n 2).
142