5
I cannot go anywhere. I cannot go back
to Bangladesh because I only had a
temporary legal stay in a refugee camp.
I cannot go back to Myanmar because
my nationality has been withdrawn.
RASHID, A STATELESS PERSON BORN IN MAUNGDAW, MYANMAR
NATASHA
RASHID
Natasha was trafficked to Slovakia in 1991 and forced
into prostitution. She was born and had lived her entire
life in a region of the former USSR (Soviet Socialist
Republic of Ukraine) which in 1991 became Moldova.
Despite escaping her captors, she thereafter spent almost
20 years in Slovakia as an irregular migrant with no
documents. She tried to contact the Moldovan Embassy
to obtain documentation and proof of nationality but this
was located in Vienna and she was not able to cross the
border without a passport. Her letters to the Embassy
had no effect. She applied for asylum several times but
always without a result. She was detained repeatedly
while the police unsuccessfully tried to deport her from
Slovakia. Hardest of all, her two children – both Slovak
citizens – were placed in care without her consent while
she was detained. This had a devastating impact on her.
Following her release from a period in detention in 2011,
based on appeals submitted, the court and later the
Slovak authorities recognised that her deportation was
not possibe while her citizenship was still undetermined.
She was reunited with her children. Eventually in 2012
she was able to make use of a discretionary power
enabling her to be granted permanent residence as
a stateless person. After more than 22 years spent in
Slovakia she was finally able to acquire all the necessary
documents – a residence permit, travel document
(Convention Travel Document) and health insurance card
in order to get on with her life. However, Slovakia still
lacks a dedicated statelessness determination procedure
to protect all stateless migrants in this situation and to
prevent their arbitrary detention.
Rashid was born in Myanmar. He fled to Bangladesh
aged 12 with his mother in 1992 after his father, who
was a Muslim rights activist, was killed and his sister
was arrested. He lived in Bangladesh for 20 years, first
in a refugee camp and then in several villages. Before
Rashid’s mother passed away in 2002 she explained
to Rashid that he did not possess a valid identity
document because the Rohingya of Myanmar had been
deprived of their Myanmar nationality. Rashid travelled
irregularly to the Netherlands in 2012. He applied for
asylum twice and his request was refused both times.
After the second rejection he was kept in immigration
detention for 8 months. He was eventually released
after being presented to the Bangladeshi and Myanmar
authorities, both of which refused to accept him as a
national. However, following his release he was unable
to regularise his stay and he remains without status and
sleeps in a homeless shelter. He has lived with instability
his entire life and now finds himself alone in a foreign
country suffering from nightmares, psychological issues
and high blood pressure (even though he is still a young
man). He cannot lead a normal life in the Netherlands
but equally he cannot go and live anywhere else.
Provided by the Human Rights League, Slovakia
Provided by the Tilburg University Statelessness Programme