116 | Report on the Situation of Human Rights in the Dominican Republic
taken away, were unable to register their own children. Thus, the Constitutional
Court rendered another generation stateless. 271
269. As previously mentioned, in operative paragraph five of judgment TC/0168/13 the
Constitutional Court ordered the Central Electoral Board to audit the Registry’s
record books for the period from 1929 to 2007, and to send a list of persons
irregularly registered with the Civil Registry to the Ministry of the Interior and
Police. The Commission observes that in compliance with the judgment in question,
on May 26, 2015 the Central Electoral Board presented the “Results of the Audit of
the Registry for the period 1929-2007.” The audit checked 116,506 volumes of
records, with 16,748,568 pages containing the Dominican Republic’s history of
records for the period in question. The Central Electoral Board found that 53,827
books, representing a total of 10,321,799 pages, contained records of persons that
needed to be checked. In the end, it was able to establish that out of all the pages
audited in the Civil Registry’s record books for the period in question, only 0.58%
contained records with possible irregularities, while the rest, 99.42%, did not
contain the kind of inconsistencies found in the 0.58%. In the words of the Chair of
the Central Electoral Board, this meant that “authorization had been given for
issuance or copies of around 53,000 records that identify persons.” The records
revealed the foreign-born parents represented a total of 103 nationalities. Of all the
records audited, the country of origin of the foreign-born parents was Haiti in
68.45% of the cases; the United States in 3.93%; Spain in 2.84%, the Republic of
China in 1.98%, and so on. 272
270. According to President Danilo Medina and Foreign Minister Andres Navarro, with
enforcement of the provisions of Law 169-14 regarding persons born in the
Dominican Republic both of whose parents are foreign nationals in an irregular
migratory situation and who were in possession of some type of document issued by
the Dominican State –in other words, those in Group A- and based on the findings of
the audit done by the Central Electoral Board, the identification documents of
approximately 55,000 will be accepted as valid and their Dominican nationality and
that of their descendants will be recognized. 273
271. As for persons born to foreign-born parents with an irregular migratory situation
and who, although born on Dominican soil, do not appear in the Civil Registry, i.e.,
271
272
273
See also, Open Society Institute, Dominicans of Haitian Descent and the Compromised Right to Nationality,
Report presented to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights on the occasion of its 140th Session,
2010, p. 6.
Dominican Republic. Nota MP-RD-OEA 0653-15: Palabras del Doctor Roberto Rosario Márquez, Presidente de la
Junta Central Electoral, el pasado 26 de mayo de 2015 en la Presentación de los Resultados de la Auditoría al
Registro Civil en los años 1929 a 2007 Dominican Republic. [Note MP-RD-OEA 0653-15: Remarks made by Dr.
Roberto Rosario Márquez, Chair of the Central Electoral Board, May 26, 2015, in presenting the findings of the
audit done of the Registry Office from 1929 to 2007], June 8, 2015. See also, Dominican Republic, JCE, Informe
de Auditoria al Registro Civil desde 1929 al 2007 [JCE, Report on the Audit of the Registry from 1929 to 2007],
May 26, 2015.
Dominican Republic, Discurso de Danilo Medina, Presidente de la República Dominicana, en el marco de la XLV
Cumbre del Sistema de Integración Latinoamericano (SICA) [Address delivered by Danilo Medina, President of
the Dominican Republic, at the XLV Summit of the Latin American Integration System (SICA)]. Guatemala, June
26, 2015; Address by Andres Navarro, Foreign Minister of the Dominican Council, before the OAS Permanent
Council, Washington, June 30, 2015.
Organization of American States | OAS
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents