The 218,000 figure should be used with caution. As discussed, many of those included in these
provisional estimates may not in fact be stateless. Some may have obtained nationality in their
own country or in a third country. Others may be stateless, but will ultimately be able to obtain
nationality in the United States. On the other hand, this figure excludes some US residents who
are potentially stateless or potentially at risk of statelessness. In short, it represents a population
of non-US citizens who fall within profiles of persons who are potentially stateless or potentially
at risk of statelessness.
For information purposes, CMS also analyzed federal immigration data—some publicly available
and some provided by the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, Inc. (TRAC) at Syracuse
University—on populations listed as “stateless” or of “unknown” nationality. This data included
populations that: (1) sought asylum “affirmatively” (not in removal proceedings) before US
Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS); (2) sought asylum “defensively,” i.e., while in
removal proceedings; (3) were placed in removal proceedings between 2001 and 2018; and, (4)
were in immigrant detention in 2018 (TRAC 2019d).
These data sources do not capture the total number of foreign-born persons who come to the
attention of federal agencies. Nor do they count stateless persons not encountered by federal
immigration officials. In addition, some persons may be incorrectly characterized in these
datasets as nationals of particular states. The report provides CMS’s analysis of this immigration
data, not to add to its estimates of those who are potentially stateless or potentially at risk of
statelessness, but to present a fuller picture of certain populations and to highlight the limitations
of US administrative data.
Section I of the report outlines the project’s methodology. Section II describes the causes of
statelessness, the legal context faced by stateless persons in the United States, CMS’s profiles
of populations that are potentially stateless or potentially at risk of statelessness in the United
States, and descriptions of certain populations not included in CMS’s estimates. Section III
provides provisional estimates of select populations that are potentially stateless or potentially
at risk of statelessness. It also sets forth the strengths and limitations of the data used to make
these estimates, and the numbers of persons listed as stateless or of unknown nationality in US
immigration and refugee datasets. Section IV describes the challenges facing stateless persons
in the United States, drawing heavily from CMS’s interviews with stateless persons and its online
survey. Section V recommends ways to improve data collection in order to better identify stateless
persons. It also outlines some of measures set forth in the 1961 Convention, US legislation, and
academic and policy literature to prevent and reduce statelessness, including a designated path
to citizenship for stateless persons. It also sets forth a series of policy recommendations to
protect and integrate stateless persons.
5
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents