Rohingya refugees – like all refugees in Malaysia –
are not officially recognised as such and instead
are considered ‘illegal’ migrants under the country’s
Immigration Act. Despite this, authorities do
allow refugees and asylum seekers to register
with UNHCR, and those who are given a UNHCR
identity card are offered some basic legal
protections. In practice, the large numbers of people
seeking asylum means that obtaining a UNHCR
card can be a lengthy process, although the
agency prioritises registration of vulnerable people
(including separated or unaccompanied children) as
well as those in detention.
While they are awaiting formal registration,
refugees are given an official ‘under consideration’
letter, which informs the authorities that UNHCR is
assessing their claim to being a person of concern.
Neither the card nor the letter grants any official
legal status in Malaysia, meaning that all refugees
in the country – including children – are at risk of
arrest, detention, deportation, and refoulement.
The Malaysian government has repeatedly asserted
that card-holders have no special status, telling
local media in April 2020: “Rohingya nationals
who are holders of the United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) card have
no status, rights or basis to make any claims on the
government.” 108 However, in practice, having
a documentation from UNHCR is a vital source
of protection, and its importance to Rohingya
refugees cannot be overstated.
On paper, Malaysia has laws that should protect
Rohingya children born in the country from
statelessness, and Article 14 of the Federal
Constitution entitles any person born in the country,
who is not already a citizen of any other country,
to Malaysian citizenship.109 In practice, this provision
is not implemented for stateless children born in
Malaysia – including Rohingya children – and most
have no formal legal status in the country. Even those
children whose families have lived Malaysia for two or
three generations are unable to acquire citizenship.
Children born to Rohingya-Malaysian marriages, who
are also legally entitled Malaysian citizenship, an also
experience difficulties in obtaining documentation.110
While Malaysia refuses to grant Rohingya children –
and other refugee children – official legal status in
the country, for the most part, those born in
Malaysia are able to obtain birth certificates to
confirm their date and place of birth, as well as the
identity of their parents. To do so requires a letter
from the hospital or clinic where the child was born,
which should be taken to the National Registration
Department (Jabatan Pendaftaran Negara, JPN) to be
officially recorded by the government. For Rohingya,
the primary use of a birth certificate is to obtain
registration with UNHCR (its child protection policy
requires a birth certificate in order for the agency
to be able to register children born in Malaysia to
their parents).111
However, access to birth registration can, in some
cases, be undermined by difficulties experienced by
pregnant Rohingya women in accessing healthcare.
While Malaysian nationals pay around 100 ringgit
($25) for delivery services, the fee for foreigners
is around 8,000 ringgit ($2,000) – an amount
that is impossible for refugees and economically
disadvantaged migrants to pay. In June 2005, the
Ministry of Health recognised the need for more
affordable healthcare for refugees, and entered into
a formal agreement with UNHCR Malaysia to allow
UN-registered refugees and ‘persons of concern’ a
50% discount on healthcare services at government
hospitals. Even with the discount though, refugees
often still struggle to pay, especially as they do not
have the right to work in Malaysia. In some hospitals,
staff claim that they do not accept UNHCR ‘under
consideration’ letters and tell women to come back
after they have been officially registered with the
agency.112 Unregistered Rohingya are not eligible for
the discount, and the costs – when coupled with the
risk of arrest for being ‘illegal’ migrants – can prevent
pregnant women from seeking assistance in medical
facilities. This not only impacts prospects for birth
registration but it also poses risks to the mother and
child in the event of pregnancy-related complications,
as well as children’s access to timely vaccinations.
3 COUNTRY BY COUNTRY SNAPSHOT
LEGAL STATUS
ACCESS TO EDUCATION
Malaysian government policy prohibits refugee
children and the children of undocumented migrant
workers from attending public schools. This has
devastating consequences for Rohingya children, and
applies regardless of whether they have just arrived
in the country or belong to families who have lived
in Malaysia for several generations. As in other
countries, lack of access to formal education limits
children’s future opportunities, exposing them to
informal and exploitative work.
In the absence of access to government schools, it
has been left to NGOs, faith-based organizations,
19