authorities. Those instruments can be a Constitution, a Presidential decree,
or a citizenship act. Most people are considered nationals by operation of
only one State’s laws – usually either the laws of the State in which the
person was born (jus soli) or the laws of the State of which the person’s
parents were nationals when the individual was born (jus sanguinis).
Whenever an administrative procedure allows for discretion in granting
citizenship, applicants for citizenship cannot be considered nationals until
their applications have been completed and approved and the citizenship
of that State is granted in accordance with the law. Individuals who have
to apply for citizenship, and those whom the law defines as eligible to apply,
but whose applications are rejected, are not citizens of that State by
operation of that State’s law.
Individuals who have not received nationality automatically or through an
individual decision under the operation of any State’s laws are known
as de jure stateless persons: persons who are stateless with reference
to applicable law.
It is presumed that an individual has a nationality unless there is some
evidence to the contrary. However, sometimes the States with which an
individual might have a genuine link cannot agree as to which of them is
the State that has granted citizenship to that person. The individual is
thus unable to demonstrate that he/she is de jure stateless, yet he/she has
no effective nationality and does not enjoy national protection. He/She
is considered to be de facto stateless.
Although the Convention’s drafters felt it was necessary to make the distinction between
de jure stateless persons (those who have not received nationality automatically or
through an individual decision under the operation of any State’s laws) and de facto
stateless persons (those who cannot establish their nationality), they did recognize the
similarity of their positions. The Final Act of the Convention addresses the issue of de
facto stateless persons with a non-binding recommendation:
“that each Contracting State, when it recognizes as valid the reasons for which
a person has renounced the protection of the State of which he is a national,
consider sympathetically the possibility of according to that person the treatment
which the Convention accords to stateless persons.”
The decision as to whether a person is entitled to the benefits of the Convention is
made by each State Party in accordance with its own established procedures. Through
its representations/offices or its services at Headquarters, UNHCR is available to provide
advice on how to create and implement these procedures, if requested. (See Annex
4 for a list of UNHCR offices.)
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents