/
/
It is worth reiterating, that from the outset some states reserve the right to
formal public education to citizens only. In these cases, the principal reason
that stateless children are excluded is directly linked to lack of citizenship. In
other instances, states may allow access to formal public education or may
offer flexible admission policies for children unable to comply with registration
criteria, including stateless children. However, a birth certificate is usually
still the minimum requirement to facilitate the school registration process
and enable a child to enrol. This means that, despite clear international
standards that stipulate primary education should be compulsory and free (and
consequently absent of any impediments that may result in the contrary), the
first barrier stateless children face when trying to register for school, occurs due
to their lack of legal documentation.
Obstacles
along the
educational
journey
Birth registration – particularly the issuance of birth certificates – may be
denied to stateless communities or unavailable due to several factors including
exclusion due to status (i.e. lack of legal status, unrecognized minority, stateless
community), discriminatory nationality laws, or discriminatory birth registration
procedures in law and practice. Without a birth certificate, other forms of legal
identification (e.g., child ID cards) may also be unavailable to stateless children,
compounding the problem of lack of documentation.
The impact of discrimination - direct and indirect – that lies at the heart of why stateless
children experience exclusion from formal education systems cannot be understated.
There are both short and long-term ramifications.
Stateless children are often left baffled and disillusioned about their identity when they
are denied access to school, which may consequently lead to anxiety, depression and a
general sense of non-belonging. Their struggles are constant and often combined with
other socio-economic challenges which further impact their self-esteem.
Without nationality and commonly also without legal identification, stateless children
frequently encounter obstacles that block their access to primary level education, with
uncertainty increasing in the transitionary period beyond primary school. As a result,
stateless children are often undereducated, or uneducated altogether. They are highly
unlikely to attain the necessary certifications or qualifications required to advance to
tertiary level education, thus negatively impacting their future.
This fragmented journey, as illustrated by Nosizi’s story at the opening of this report,
can lead to confusion, resentment, broken dreams, and feelings of failure. In addition,
because stateless people face restrictions participating in the formal work sector, with
many professions often reserved for citizens, their reality – marked by undereducation,
a lack of recognized qualifications, and restricted access to certain professions – plays a
significant role in the decision to persevere with their education at all, thereby leading
to higher dropout rates among stateless children.
OBSTACLE 1: ENROLLING IN PRIMARY SCHOOL
Even where schools apply a flexible approach and accommodate children
without birth registration or legal identification, a lack of safeguards to
guarantee continuous access to education for those without documentation
nevertheless means stateless children face periodic requests for documentation
that they cannot comply with. This leads to disruptions or termination of their
education.
/
OBSTACLE 2: COMPLETING PRIMARY SCHOOL
AND ENTERING SECONDARY SCHOOL
When transitioning from primary to secondary education, another set
of obstacles arise for stateless children. As they enter the stage of “noncompulsory” education, there are several critical junctures that impact a
stateless student’s educational progression:
•
End of Primary School: Most schools require an identity document to
register and sit end of primary school exams, which are a pre-requisite to
enter high school and also to receive a diploma certifying completion of
primary studies.
9