Clients rejected for late registration of birth
If the reason for the rejection is that the application does not meet
the requirements for LRB contained in regulation 4 and 5, it may be
necessary to apply for a certificate of citizenship in cases of doubt in
terms of section 15 of the Citizenship Act (see par. 5.1.6). If the
reasons are not justified in term of the Act or Regulations, or if no
reasons are received within 90 days, the decision may be taken on
judicial review.
Should the Department decline to approve a client’s application
for late birth registration, the client is entitled to written reasons for
the decision in terms of section 5 (1) of PAJA. The first step which
you can take on behalf of your client is thus to request that such
written reasons be provided.
If you either receive written reasons and the reasons are
unsatisfactory, or you do not receive any response to your request,
your clients will have grounds for the judicial review of this decision
or an internal appeal of the decision. According to section 5 (2) of
the PAJA, the reasons given for the Department’s decision to refuse
to approve your client’s application must be ‘adequate’. It is also
stipulated in section 5 (3), that the decision will be regarded as
being taken without good reason should the local office fail to
provide adequate written reasons. You may decide to pursue
judicial review of the decision at the outset. Your client is entitled to
this procedure. It may be more effective, however, in practice, to
refer the application and the reasons for its refusal to either the
District Manager or the Deputy Director-General for Civic Services.
If the client and his witness are at any stage called in for
interviews, prepare the client and witnesses for this interview.
Request to be present at the interview ahead of time (see section
3(3)(a) of PAJA; legal representation may be necessary to protect
the client's right to just administrative action). The client and his/
her witness will be interviewed separately and their answers will be
compared against each other to evaluate credibility and veracity.
Advise your client's witness not to make any statements to which
they do not have personal knowledge. Accompany the client and
his witness to the interview and ask for minutes to be given to you
following the interview.
Birth to a single father or to an undocumented mother and
South African father
76
Promoting citizenship and preventing statelessness in South Africa: A practitioner’s guide
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents