1.5.2 Colonial Legacies
One distinctive factor for statelessness in Asia is the legacy of colonialism; most states in Asia today were colonized by European powers to
varying degrees, with Thailand (Kingdom of Siam), Japan, and to some
extent Iran being the main exceptions. Within the field of statelessness
studies, scholars are beginning to explore the connections between colonialism and statelessness,104 calling for ‘the value of decoloniality as a
tool to understand and critically analyse statelessness’.105 Several chapters in this book contribute important analysis to this ongoing work.
These chapters highlight the long-lasting legacies of colonial rule on
statelessness in at least three ways, namely the adoption of the nationstate model, the failure to fully integrate populations which arrived
through mass colonial-era migration, as well as policies and practices
tied to the logic of colonial racial classification that regulate populations
and belonging.
First, many protracted situations of statelessness in the region have
deep roots in the ways through which countries in the region adopted the
nation-state model during and after colonialization. Western-derived
concepts of race/ethnicity, nationhood and citizenship were imposed
on Asian countries during the twentieth century.106 Decolonization and
statehood perpetuated sometimes arbitrary borders drawn by colonial
powers, which encompassed rich ethnic, linguistic and cultural diversity
but also divided traditional communities across newly rigidifed state
borders. For example, Ismatov in Chapter 4 observes that in 1924, the
Soviet policymakers undertook a ‘massive and clumsy border delimitation process and created five stans in order to consolidate power and
promote socialism’. These borders were approximate: ‘people were
mixed, and the boundaries between them porous’.107
104
Choudhury, (n 53).
Malak Benslama-Dabdoub, ‘Decolonising Statelessness: Unpacking Colonial Legacies
and Deconstructing Forms of Epistemic Violence’ (Critical Statelessness Studies,
January 2021) <https://law.unimelb.edu.au/centres/statelessness/resources/critical-state
lessness-studies-blog/decolonising-statelessness-unpacking-colonial-legacies-and-decon
structing-forms-of-epistemic-violence> accessed 13 September 2023.
106
See Leo Suryadinata, The Making of Southeast Asian Nations: State, Ethnicity,
Indigenism and Citizenship (World Scientific 2014); and Arif Dirlik, ‘Colonialism,
Revolution, Development: A Historical Perspective on Citizenship in Political
Struggles in Eastern Asia’ (2010) 39(2) Development and Society 187.
107
Citing Vanessa Ruget, ‘Citizenship in Central Asia’ in Engin F. Isin and Peter Nyers
(eds), Routledge Handbook of Global Citizenship Studies (Routledge 2014) 336.
105
https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009399555.003 Published online by Cambridge University Press