standard of living.”382 Inward-looking tendencies and the focus on current
realities affect the extent to which political remedies are addressed. In other
words, another “characteristic that distinguishes oppressed people [is] a
sense of drowning in the present, an inability to envision the future, and a
capacity to only connect with the past and its amplified pain.”383
This failure to recognize the political and historical paths that have led to the
current situation, a satisfaction with only concentrating on the existing reality,
and resorting to self-blame, characterize how the Fahmawi society specifically,
and the Palestinian society generally, deal with their current social issues —
through depoliticization. Such patterns have consistently characterized people
living under colonialism and religious persecution. This type of prolonged
repression, juxtaposed with a failure to deter or counteract foreign control,
eventually evolve into feelings of helplessness and a deep sense of guilt.
Colonial regimes also attempt to perpetuate a mentality in the minds of those
colonized that they are to blame for their current situation and that they need
colonial rule to reform and be ‘civilized’.
Asrar Kayyal, Psychologist
Umm al-Fahm, 7 November 2019
Altering the Political Identity of Umm al-Fahm
When the politics of geographical dislocation are considered, alongside the
attempted alteration of the Palestinian identity of those who hold Israeli
citizenship, (particularly Palestinians in Umm al-Fahm), the intent of the policy
becomes clear. A commonly held belief is that the “geographical location is
not a factor that determines who Palestinians are, [it is their] history and
collective identity [that] determine [their] Palestinian-hood.”384 However, the
absence of an organically and suitably connected road and transportation
system undermines the potential for the formation and sustainment of
the collective identity of the Palestinian people. Instead this causes the
evolution of a separate inward-looking approach, alongside concurrent
spatial restructuring, which gradually erases traces of past connections and
interrelations. As such, the very purpose of Israeli policies on Umm al-Fahm
382 Fahmawi Youth Movement, supra 301.
383 Under the phenomenon of ‘permanence disorder’ characterized by Mustafa Hegazy in Social
Retardation: An Introduction to the Psychology of the Defeated Man, Arab Cultural Center (Beirut,
1891), Asrar Kayyal adds that “National groups that suffer from permanence disorder can only be
liberated from it when they become aware of the causes of their oppression and find ways to confront
them instead of opposing one another and engaging in persecution violence. Asrar Kayyal, supra 380.
384 Loai al-Khatib, Member of the Political Office of Abnaa al-Balad, interview conducted by BADIL, 6
November 2019.
94
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents