3.2.3. The Isolation of Umm al-Fahm
Isolation lies at the core of the Israeli strategy to confine, concentrate and
disconnect Umm al-Fahm from its surroundings, completing the broader system
of the city’s fragmentation and segregation. Since Israel has a stranglehold on
urban planning and transportation decision-making, its policies of isolation
are enacted in a subtle and largely inconspicuous way, rather than through
explicit targeting of Palestinian communities. “Cities’ structural maps and the
permission or prevention of building play a primary role in either creating
successful cities or poor and marginalized ones,”318 and Israel has cunningly
shaped Umm al-Fahm’s design through its centralized decision-making
processes.
Trade is what increases a city’s value. Israel follows a strategic annexation
policy in some cities as is most suitable for its purposes. For example, Israel
connected the area of Wadi ‘Ara with other Israeli-Jewish areas, while it
separated and excluded the city of Umm Al-Fahm in order to keep it both
isolated and industrially dependent.
Engineer #1
Interview: Umm al-Fahm, 7 November 2019
This control enables the manipulation of road planning and transportation
decision-making for the purpose of de facto de-development. Structural
maps are designed according to Israeli-Jewish priorities and are at odds
with Palestinian needs.319 Then, constrained by an ill-suited planning system
that leaves them with no leeway to develop, Palestinian cities grow without
proper and adapted planning, often in an uneven manner and inevitably
manifesting social discord. This, in turn, conveys the unwarranted impression
that Palestinian cities are unsuitable for proper planning and are responsible
for their own problems. The resulting situation then justifies the further
tightening of control over Palestinian communities through intensified
policing and constant interference.
To achieve this, Israel utilizes a number of isolating practices. Among these are
the absence of planning for social public spaces such as parks and recreational
centers, residential areas according to housing needs,320 as well as health
facilities, particularly hospitals. While this is all intentional, it is legitimized
under the guise of preserving an assumedly objective planning system.
318 Traffic and Transportation Engineer, interview conducted by BADIL, Nazareth, 8 November 2019.
319 Jabbarin, supra 281.
320 Engineer, interview conducted by BADIL, Umm al-Fahm, 7 November 2019.
81
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents