the protection of refugee rights. It is instead shorthand for a long-standing
colonial logic: preserving the geopolitical status quo, preventing refugee
return, and ensuring the containment of Palestinian political identity
within fragmented, aid-dependent systems. This securitized framework
prioritizes the interests of the Israeli regime and Western donor states
over the liberation, and justice owed to a forcibly displaced Palestinian
population.
As the Assessment itself states, UNRWA has “contributed to Israel’s
security by preserving stability in fragile environments.”39 In other words,
the Assessment portrays UNRWA’s survival not as a safeguard of refugee
rights until the implementation of Resolution 194, but as a buffer to
prevent the destabilization of the Israeli colonial-apartheid regime.
Regional “stability” in this context is a euphemism for maintaining
displacement, colonialism, and enforced dependency—allowing the
Israeli regime to entrench its crimes while outsourcing the humanitarian
fallout to international actors.
Ultimately, the Assessment fails to center UNRWA’s mandate and its crucial
role in supporting the fulfillment of Resolution 194, particularly the right
to reparations and reconstruction in Gaza. The Assessment acknowledges
that UNRWA’s collapse would mark a “significant abandonment of
Palestine refugees by the international community at a time of great
suffering.”40 However, it frames this collapse as a threat to the two-state
solution, as it is “receiving renewed commitment, and when the staff of
UNRWA are crucial to recovery in Gaza and to Palestinian governance in
the West Bank.”41 The cessation of UNRWA is not (and should not be)
tied to the two-state solution, as long as that solution is enforced without
implementing Article 11 of Resolution 194, which affirms the rights of
39 United Nations. Report to the Secretary-General: UNRWA Strategic Assessment, 2025,1.
40 United Nations. Report to the Secretary-General: UNRWA Strategic Assessment, 2025, 24.
41 United Nations. Report to the Secretary-General: UNRWA Strategic Assessment, 2025, 24.
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents