to police stations from remote areas without
transport facilities and loss of livelihoods has
placed severe hardship on stateless people,
exacerbated by government mandated restrictions on movement. Many released detainees
found themselves having to walk long distances to report to police stations as per their bail
terms which were not relaxed even during the
lockdown. Stateless persons who are not yet
fear of arrest and even though there are no
formal restrictions, there is a fear of migrating
for work in case of apprehension, detention or
harassment by the police and vigilante groups,
particularly if they have to migrate beyond Assam into neighbouring states. Those still in detention live in inhumane living conditions with
inadequate medical facilities.
Lawyer specialising
in legal support to people at risk of
statelessness in Assam, Aman Wadud
Maijaan was released from detention after the
Supreme Court ordered the release of those
who have been detained for two or more years.
She must now report to the police station every
week. Her husband migrates for work, but she
cannot go with him because of this reporting
livelihood, placing the family in a very precarious
situation as they have to repay the loan they took
STATELESSNESS AND
THE RIGHT TO NATIONALITY IN INDIA
The 1949 Constitution of India19 (rev. 2016) and
the Citizenship Act 195520 (last amended 2019)
set the rules for citizenship in India. According
acquiring Indian Citizenship: birth, descent, registration, naturalisation and the incorporation
of territories.21 In 1986 the Citizenship Act was
amended stating that a child born in India can
only get Indian citizenship if at least one parent
is an Indian citizen and the other is not an ‘illegal migrant’. Another amendment made in 2003
stated that a child born in India was eligible
for citizenship acquisition only if both parents
were Indian citizens at the time of the child’s
birth. In 2003 the Act was amended again in
Section 3(1)(b) stating that persons born after
1 July 1987 in India shall be a citizen if either
parent is an Indian citizen. This does not however provide safeguards against statelessness for
individuals born after 1 July 1987 to non-citizen
parents.22 Indian law also does not provide extra safeguards against new cases of childhood
statelessness in such situations.
Another risk of statelessness is posed by Section 5 of the Citizenship Act. This provision
provides for individuals without citizenship who
are residing in India to acquire citizenship by
registration if certain criteria are met.23 However, this provision excludes those deemed as
‘illegal migrants’.24 As a consequence, many
residents without citizenship remain at risk of
statelessness. In 2019, the government passed
the contested Citizenship (Amendment) Act
2019, which facilitates citizenship to six specdesh and Pakistan that entered India before
31 December 2014. However, the Law is discriminatory on the basis of religion, excluding
Muslims.25 Consequently, Muslim migrants or
refugees from the above-mentioned states face
a greater risk of statelessness. The Act also
discriminates against Sri Lankan refugees of
all religions who have been in India for the last
thirty years. In August 2019, the Supreme Court
ruled that a child born after 3 December 2004
will not be included in the NRC if either parent
is considered a ‘doubtful voter’ or declared a
‘foreigner’26 thus making them ineligible for Indian citizenship and putting the child at risk of
statelessness.
THE CESF CONSORTIUM PROJECT
18
Case Study: Maijaan Nessa, 38, belongs to
Assamese Muslim ethnicity. She is married to
Momresh Al, a Bengali Muslim form the Barpeta
District of Assam. She was marked as a doubtful voter and eventually had to appear before a
FT which declared her a ‘foreigner’ in 2015. She
was called to the police station to give her thumb
print so that the case would be dismissed but instead was arrested and detained without any prior notice and without being allowed to inform her
family. She was detained in Kokrajhar Detention
Camp for four years and ten months.
Maijaan has three daughters and two sons. Her
eldest son was 18 years at the time of her detention and unable to deal with the stress of his
mother’s detention, the trauma of which led to his
untimely death. Her other children were minors
at the time. She and her husband are illiterate
and from very poor socio-economic background.
Her husband works odd jobs including as a rikshaw-puller, carpenter and daily wage worker.
Fighting Maijaan’s legal battle has been traumat-
22
The aim of this project, carried out by DAJI, is to empower communities at risk of statelessness to
access COVID-19 relief, social protection services and legal aid. At the state level, this project aims
to increase access to COVID-19 relief measures and social services for people affected by FTs
level, this project aims to strengthen the RNCN that aims to campaign and advocate for the right
to nationality as a human right. RNCN-DAJI are undertaking several documentation, research and
advocacy efforts related to COVID-19 response, detention and FTs. These include documenting
the impact of FTs in the context of COVID-19 on individuals and families through engagement with
clients and their lawyers. This project is currently pioneering three different advocacy campaigns:
on the child’s right to nationality, inclusive COVID-19 responses and social security and on fair and
just trial procedures in the FTs. As such, the project aims to engage and advocate before different
Commission and UN agencies including UNHCR and UNICEF.
DAJI works with marginalised communities to empower them to realise their rights, access services and protect their freedoms. DAJI works with refugees, minorities, displaced people and people
at risk of statelessness through community mobilisation, education, training and humanitarian support.
Impact
The RNCN/DAJI report27 on the exclusion of stateless people from COVID-19 response and social
security provisions of the state has been disseminated to many national and international stakeholders. The report was launched in a webinar in February 2021. Highlights of the report were
posted on RNCN social media accounts and reached over 500 followers. DAJI has further supported more than 600 families in Assam to reach out to authorities on birth registrations, particularly
of children born during the pandemic, and reached out to government authorities and UNICEF in
Assam to facilitate corrective steps. DAJI is also advocating for access to other social security
provisions including subsidised food, pensions for the elderly and disabled persons. DAJI is currently supporting 40 stateless persons to challenge the charges against them in the FTs. Lawyers
and paralegals associated with legal aid efforts have been trained and the community has been
supported by them to address problems they are likely to face when challenging their exclusion
from the NRC. The RNCN network is further being strengthened to include people with expertise of
different disciplines related to citizenship.