domestic laws currently in force in the ASEAN region provide specifically for the legal status of
“stateless person”. As a consequence, the status of stateless persons often remains ambiguous or is dealt
with on an ad hoc basis as cases come to the attention of the state. Thus, in Malaysia for instance, the
Immigration Act (Act 1959/63) does not differentiate between refugees, asylum-seekers and stateless
persons.164 However, section 55 (1) of the Immigration Act gives the Home Minister the power to
exempt any person or group from the provisions of the Act. This section provides a legal basis for
promoting the protection of certain groups and individuals by offering them a temporary residence
permit called the IMM13. In 2006, the government announced it would use this avenue to improve the
legal status of people from the Muslim population of northern Rakhine State in Myanmar who had
settled in Malaysia, whose situation is characterised by both statelessness and asylum-related concerns.
A registration exercise was initiated to issue IMM13 permits to Muslims of northern Rakhine State in
order to allow them to work, attend school and live in the country legally. This exercise was later
suspended, but it nevertheless illustrates what steps could be taken to provide a stateless population
with a stable legal status and promote their enjoyment of rights through ad hoc remedies based on
existing domestic law.165 A similar approach has also been seen in Thailand where, over the years,
successive Cabinet Resolutions established a dedicated legal status for specified categories of nonnationals present in Thailand and granted temporary permission to reside under article 17 of the
Immigration Act.166 In this way, many stateless persons in Thailand have been able to access a legal
status of some kind, contributing significantly to their enjoyment of rights.167
6.2 Promoting access to personal documentation
The enjoyment of rights often hinges, in practice, on a person’s ability to identify him or herself and
show proof of legal status. A second critical element in protecting the rights of stateless persons is
therefore the issuance of some form of personal documentation. Ideally, stateless persons would be
issued with documents that vouch for both their identity and their status as a stateless person.168 In
Thailand, for instance, as successive groups of non-nationals were granted a legal status under the
immigration law, identity cards were also developed that verified this legal status.169
Persons: Implementation within European Union Member States and Recommendations for Harmonisation, UNHCR, October
2003.
164
UN Human Rights Council, Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education, Vernor Munoz Villalobos:
addendum: mission to Malaysia, A/HRC/11/8/Add.2, 20 March 2009.
165
International Federation for Human Rights, Undocumented migrants and refugees in Malaysia: Raids, detention and
discrimination, 19 March 2008; US Committee for Refugees and Immigrants, World Refugee Survey 2009 – Malaysia, 17 June
2009; M. Lynch; K. Southwick, Nationality rights for all: A progress report and global survey on statelessness, Refugees
International, 2009; Equal Rights Trust, Trapped in a circle of flight: Stateless Rohingya in Malaysia, January 2010.
166
Thus, for example, a Cabinet Resolution passed on 17 March 1992 granted legal migrant status to the Thai Lue who had
been identified as lacking Thai nationality. Meanwhile, hill tribe people who were established in Thailand before 3 October
1985 – but did not hold Thai nationality – were granted the permanent right to reside in the country under Cabinet Resolutions
passed in 1995 and 2000. Tang Lay Lee, Statelessness, human rights and gender: irregular migrant workers from Burma in
Thailand, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2005; International Rescue Committee, Basic information on rights of migrant workers
in Thailand, IRC Protection Team, Bangkok Office, January 2006; UNESCO, Citizenship Manual – Capacity building on
birth registration and citizenship in Thailand, 2008; US Department of State, 2007 Country Reports on Human Rights
Practices – Thailand, 11 March 2008.
167
In addition, it has opened avenues for the prevention of statelessness among children of persons who hold one of these
dedicated statuses and will facilitate the reduction of statelessness as Thailand develops new policies in this area. This shows
how efforts to protect stateless persons can complement and reinforce the prevention and reduction of statelessness. Punthip
Kanchanachittra Saisoonthorn, “Development of concepts of nationality and the efforts to reduce statelessness in Thailand” in
Refuge Survey Quarterly, Vol. 25, Issue 3, 2006; L. van Waas, Is permanent illegality inevitable? The challenge to ensuring
birth registration and the right to a nationality for the children of irregular migrants – Thailand and the Dominican Republic,
Plan International, 2006; UNESCO, Citizenship Manual – Capacity building on birth registration and citizenship in Thailand,
2008.
168
This is one of the special measures provided for in the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, under
which state parties are to issue identity documents to any stateless persons in their territory. Article 27 of the 1954 Convention
relating to the Status of Stateless Persons.
169
The multitude of specific legal statuses created led to a complex system of colour-coded cards, which has more recently
been merged with the regular identity card system using 13-digit personal identification numbers. International Rescue
Committee, Basic information on rights of migrant workers in Thailand, IRC Protection Team, Bangkok Office, January 2006;
UNESCO, Citizenship Manual – Capacity building on birth registration and citizenship in Thailand, 2008; US Department of
State, 2007 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices – Thailand, 11 March 2008.
25